Home › Conditions › Mental Capacity Assessment
Psychiatry
Mental Capacity Assessment
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 (MCA) presumes all adults have capacity unless proven otherwise. Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific — a patient may lack capacity for one decision but retain it for another. The four-stage test must be applied and documented whenever capacity is in doubt.
Mental Capacity Act 2005 Four-Stage Test
The pathway
Stage 1 — Impairment/disturbance
- Does the person have an impairment or disturbance in the functioning of their mind or brain?
- Examples: dementia, delirium, intoxication, brain injury, psychiatric illness, severe learning disability
- If NO → person has capacity (assessment ends)
- If YES → proceed to Stage 2
Stage 2 — Does the impairment affect this decision?
- Does the impairment/disturbance affect their ability to make this specific decision at this time?
- If NO → person has capacity
- If YES → assess the four functional abilities (Stages 3a–3d)
Stage 3a — Can they UNDERSTAND?
- Can the person understand the information relevant to the decision?
- Use simple language, visual aids if needed
- Provide information in an accessible format
- Understanding does not require perfect recall
Stage 3b — Can they RETAIN?
- Can the person retain the information long enough to make a decision?
- Short-term retention is sufficient — does not need to be permanent
- Strategies: written information, repeat consultations
Stage 3c — Can they WEIGH UP?
- Can the person use or weigh the information as part of the decision-making process?
- Inability to weigh: acute psychosis, severe depression, mania
- Note: a patient can make an unwise decision and still have capacity
Stage 3d — Can they COMMUNICATE?
- Can the person communicate their decision by any means?
- Any method counts: speech, writing, AAC devices, eye gaze, gesture
- Only fails this test if no method of communication is possible
If lacks capacity — Best Interests
- Follow Section 4 MCA Best Interests checklist
- Consider: past wishes, values and beliefs, advance decisions (ADRT), Lasting Power of Attorney (LPA) holder (health & welfare)
- Involve family/carers and IMCA (Independent Mental Capacity Advocate) if appropriate
- Least restrictive option principle
- DoLS: if admission to hospital or care home deprives liberty in a person lacking capacity — complete Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) form
- Complex decisions → Court of Protection
Document thoroughly
- WHO assessed capacity, WHEN, and for WHICH decision
- What information was given and in what format
- Why they were found to have/lack capacity (which stage failed)
- What was decided in their best interests and who was consulted
- Record any ADRT or LPA reviewed
When to escalate
- Patient refusing life-saving treatment and capacity is uncertain — urgent senior/psychiatric review and legal advice
- Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment (ADRT) present — verify validity and applicability before proceeding
- Deprivation of liberty without DoLS authorisation — complete DoLS paperwork urgently (unlawful deprivation is a human rights breach)
- No LPA/ADRT and family disagreement with clinical best interests decision — Court of Protection application
- Fluctuating capacity in acute delirium — reassess frequently, treat reversible causes, delay non-urgent decisions
- Patient under 16 with disputed capacity/refusal — parental consent or court order; consult paediatric team and legal
Reference: Mental Capacity Act 2005 / MCA Code of Practice 2007
Practise and explore
Practise a case or explore differentials here on the website. The optional browser app adds personal learning tools and saved progress.