Home › Cases › Breathless on Day Six
Hospital-Acquired Pneumonia
Breathless on Day Six
6 questions
Question 1 · Is it pneumonia?
Correct answer: Examine, request a CXR, and actively consider pulmonary oedema and PE before committing to pneumonia
Why
A new oxygen requirement with a fever on day 6 is not automatically pneumonia. Six days of 2.5L IV fluid a day in a 74-year-old is a lot, and pulmonary oedema looks exactly like this. So does PE after a hemiarthroplasty, and so does aspiration or atelectasis.
The NG250 definition of HAP is pneumonia 48 hours or more after admission — he qualifies on timing, but timing is not diagnosis. Examine him, get the CXR, look at the fluid balance chart and the JVP.
Key point
Day 6 plus a fever is not a diagnosis. Rule out oedema, PE and aspiration before you commit.
Question 2 · Investigations
Correct answer: A respiratory sample — sputum, nasopharyngeal swab or tracheal aspirate — for microbiology
Why
NG250 asks for a respiratory sample routinely in HAP, where in CAP it is conditional. The reason is the whole point of HAP: the organism may be resistant, and you cannot narrow the antibiotic later if you never sent anything.
CURB-65 does not apply here. It is derived and validated for community-acquired pneumonia, and NG250 makes a research recommendation on HAP severity scoring precisely because no validated tool exists. Severity in HAP is clinical judgement.
Key point
Send a sample — routine in HAP. And CURB-65 is for CAP; using it here will mislead you.
Question 3 · The decision that matters
Correct answer: Oral co-amoxiclav 500/125mg TDS for 5 days, then review
Why
Resistance risk, not the word 'hospital', decides the antibiotic. He has none of the NG250 higher-risk features: onset is day 6 but he has had no broad-spectrum antibiotics, no MDR colonisation, no recent healthcare contact before admission and no relevant comorbidity.
NG250 1.7.2 says people with onset in days 3–5 who are not at higher risk of resistance can follow the community-acquired choices. He is non-severe and can swallow, so oral co-amoxiclav is right.
Reaching for pip-tazo reflexively costs him a C. difficile risk he did not need to take.
Key point
Higher risk of resistance is the question, not severity alone. Broad-spectrum has a price.
Question 4 · A different patient
Correct answer: IV antibiotics guided by microbiology advice and local resistance data — she has three higher-risk features
Why
She has three of the higher-risk criteria: onset beyond 5 days, recent broad-spectrum antibiotics, and recent contact with a health or social care setting before admission. With a NEWS2 of 7 she is also severe.
That combination is what moves you to IV first-line cover — piperacillin-tazobactam, ceftazidime, ceftriaxone, cefuroxime or meropenem, chosen on microbiology advice and your local resistance data, not from a list in an app.
Do not wait for the sputum. Send it, then treat.
Key point
Three risk features and a NEWS2 of 7 is a different patient with the same diagnosis.
Question 5 · Day five
Correct answer: Review at 5 days and consider stopping, since he is clinically stable
Why
NG250 1.7.5: review after a total of 5 days and consider stopping if clinically stable. He is afebrile, off oxygen and eating — that is stable.
HAP does not carry an automatic longer course, and continuing 'to be safe' is how resistance and C. difficile happen. The culture result also confirms the choice rather than prompting escalation.
Key point
Five days, then review and consider stopping. Longer is a decision, not a default.
Question 6 · The bit you can actually change
Correct answer: Sit him up, request a swallow assessment, ask for early physiotherapy, and review whether his PPI is still indicated
Why
HAP is substantially preventable, and most of the levers are nursing and F1 jobs: sit them up at 30–45°, swallow assessment where indicated, mouth care, early mobilisation and physiotherapy after surgery, and reviewing the PPI — acid suppression is a risk factor and a great many inpatient PPIs have no ongoing indication.
Prophylactic antibiotics are not the answer and would make resistance worse.
Key point
Sitting them up, a swallow assessment and stopping the unneeded PPI are all yours to do.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.