Home › Cases › Three Ribs and a Blood Thinner
Rib Fractures
Three Ribs and a Blood Thinner
6 questions
Question 1 · First look
Correct answer: Whether she can take a deep breath and cough
Why
The fracture is not the problem; the breathing is. Pain splints the chest, deep breaths stop, secretions are not cleared, and the pneumonia arrives on day 3 — caused by a decision made on day 0.
Displacement barely changes management in a patient who is not going to theatre. Apixaban is not reversed for a closed rib fracture with no bleeding — but it does matter, because it scores 4 points on STUMBL and it raises the risk of a delayed haemothorax.
The question that changes what you do in the next hour is whether she can take a deep breath.
Key point
The target is a deep breath and a cough, not a pain score and not the appearance of the film.
Question 2 · Score it
Correct answer: Discuss with critical care — she is above the high-risk threshold
Why
11 or more means admit. 26 or more means discuss with critical care, and she is at 28.
That conversation is not a request for a bed — it is a conversation about the level of monitoring and the analgesic plan, and about whether she needs a block. An 81-year-old with COPD, three ribs and an anticoagulant is the exact patient STUMBL was derived to identify.
In the over-65s each additional fractured rib raises mortality and the risk of pneumonia, so three ribs in her is a different problem from three ribs in a 30-year-old.
Key point
STUMBL ≥11 admit, ≥26 discuss with critical care. Under 11 may go home with a plan, not just a prescription.
Question 3 · Prescribing
Correct answer: Regular paracetamol 1g QDS, a titrated regular strong opioid with an antiemetic and a laxative, and an NSAID only if her renal function, bleeding risk and cardiac history allow
Why
Regular, not as-required. PRN analgesia in chest wall injury means the patient is in pain before each dose, and pain is what stops them breathing deeply.
A strong opioid is titrated and prescribed with an antiemetic and a laxative — constipation and nausea are the reasons people stop taking it.
The NSAID is genuinely useful in chest wall pain and is often withheld reflexively — but she is 81, on an anticoagulant, with unknown renal function. Only if renal function, bleeding risk and cardiac history allow, and with gastric protection.
Key point
Regular, not PRN. Opioid with an antiemetic and a laxative. NSAID only if the kidneys, the bleeding risk and the heart allow it.
Question 4 · One hour later
Correct answer: Analgesia that has not worked is an escalation, not a rewrite — ask for a regional block now
Why
Reassess within an hour is in the pathway for exactly this moment. If pain still prevents deep breathing, the answer is regional analgesia, not more opioid — more opioid in an 81-year-old with COPD buys sedation and a lower respiratory rate, which is the opposite of what she needs.
Ask anaesthetics or the acute pain team by name and early. Serratus anterior and erector spinae plane blocks are the usual options.
Oxygen treats the number, not the cause. Her target range is 88–92% anyway, given the COPD.
Key point
Do not keep adding opioid. The block exists to prevent the pneumonia, so it is worth far less on day 3 than today.
Question 5 · Preventing the pneumonia
Correct answer: Physiotherapy and incentive spirometry from day one, sitting upright, with a watch for deterioration on day 2 to 4
Why
Physiotherapy from day one, not when the sats fall. By the time the saturations fall the secretions are already retained.
Never strap or bind the chest — it reduces expansion and causes the exact complication it looks like it is preventing. It is an old practice that persists because it feels supportive.
Prophylactic antibiotics are not part of the pathway. Watch for the pneumonia on day 2–4: rising temperature, new oxygen requirement, falling volumes.
Key point
Physio and spirometry from day one, upright, coughing with the chest supported. Never strap the chest.
Question 6 · Going home
Correct answer: At least a week of REGULAR analgesia with a plan to step down, explicit safety-netting, and a warning that the pain typically peaks at day 2 to 3 and takes six weeks or more to settle
Why
Regular analgesia for at least a week, with a plan to step down rather than stop — people stop the day they feel better, the pain returns, and they stop breathing deeply again.
Safety-net explicitly: fever, worsening breathlessness or new confusion means come back.
And tell them the timeline. If nobody says the pain peaks at day 2–3 and takes six weeks or more, then feeling worse tomorrow reads as a failure of treatment rather than the expected course.
Key point
Regular analgesia for a week with a step-down plan, explicit safety-netting, and the honest timeline: worse at day 2–3, six weeks to settle.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.