Home › Cases › The Faint on the Stairs
Severe Aortic Stenosis
The Faint on the Stairs
6 questions
Question 1 · The presentation
Correct answer: Exertional syncope with an ejection systolic murmur marks a sharply worse prognosis
Why
Syncope occurring DURING exertion is a major cardiac red flag, and with a slow-rising pulse and a murmur radiating to the carotids it points squarely at severe aortic stenosis.
The triad is exertional syncope, angina and breathlessness, and once symptoms appear, untreated survival shortens markedly. Syncope is the symptom that should get the fastest cardiology response.
Rapid recovery is a feature of vasovagal syncope — but syncope during exertion is a cardiac red flag, and it overrides the reassuring recovery. (Syncope shortly after stopping exercise is a different matter and can still be vasovagal.)
Key point
Syncope during exertion is a cardiac red flag. With this murmur, severe aortic stenosis until proven otherwise.
Question 2 · Grading it at the bedside
Correct answer: Murmur loudness cannot reliably grade severity — severe AS can be relatively quiet
Why
Murmur loudness cannot reliably grade severity — severe AS can have a relatively quiet murmur, because a stenotic valve with a failing ventricle generates little flow and therefore little noise.
The bedside features that suggest severe disease are a slow-rising, low-volume pulse, a narrow pulse pressure — hers is 118/96, which is 22 — a late-peaking murmur, and a quiet or absent second heart sound.
The test is the echocardiogram, and her narrow pulse pressure is the sort of finding that should get it done quickly.
Key point
Murmur loudness cannot grade severity. Slow-rising pulse and narrow pulse pressure are the clues.
Question 3 · A dangerous prescription
Correct answer: Profound hypotension — a fixed outflow tract cannot compensate for the fall in preload
Why
This is the classic ward harm in aortic stenosis. GTN drops preload; a fixed outflow tract cannot increase cardiac output to compensate, so the blood pressure falls and does not recover.
The same caution applies to other vasodilators and to aggressive diuresis, and to spinal and epidural anaesthesia — which is why the anaesthetist must be told about the valve before any list.
If hypotension does occur, the answer is fluid and a vasopressor under senior guidance, not more vasodilator.
Key point
GTN can cause profound hypotension in severe AS. The same applies to spinals and to over-diuresis.
Question 4 · The bleeding question
Correct answer: Heyde syndrome — aortic stenosis with bleeding from angiodysplasia (worth knowing rather than acting on)
Why
Heyde syndrome links aortic stenosis with gastrointestinal bleeding from angiodysplasia, through an acquired von Willebrand abnormality caused by shear stress across the stenotic valve.
It is worth knowing because it reframes an unexplained iron deficiency in an elderly patient with a murmur, and because the bleeding can improve after valve replacement.
The other associations to hold: conduction disease from calcification spreading into the septum, endocarditis risk on an abnormal valve, and atrial fibrillation being poorly tolerated, because the atrial contribution to filling matters more here than usual.
Key point
A pearl: Heyde syndrome — AS with angiodysplastic GI bleeding. The one to act on is that AF is poorly tolerated in severe AS.
Question 5 · A different patient, same problem
Correct answer: Tell anaesthetics; urgent echo if significant valve disease is suspected and it would change management
Why
Flag the murmur to anaesthetics, and obtain an urgent echo where significant valve disease is suspected and the result would change management. An undiagnosed severe aortic stenosis changes the anaesthetic technique, the monitoring and sometimes the decision to operate at all — which is exactly when a scan is worth doing. It is not a reason to echo every murmur.
The anaesthetist has to know, because a spinal in severe AS can cause a hypotension that is very hard to retrieve.
Cancelling permanently is not the answer either — most patients with AS can have necessary surgery safely, provided the valve is known about and planned for.
Key point
Tell the anaesthetist; scan when it would change management. Not every murmur needs an echo before theatre.
Question 6 · Disposal
Correct answer: Do not discharge without a cardiology conversation — symptomatic severe AS needs urgent referral
Why
Symptomatic severe aortic stenosis is an urgent cardiology referral, and the treatment is valve replacement — surgical or transcatheter.
A patient who has had exertional syncope with this examination should not leave the department on a routine request, because the interval to the next event is not predictable and she has already had one.
Asymptomatic severe AS is different: that is surveillance, not admission. Symptoms are the whole hinge.
Key point
Symptoms change everything. Exertional syncope with this murmur does not go home on a routine request.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.