Home › Cases › Typing the Failure
Type 1 Resp Failure
Typing the Failure
6 questions
Question 1 · The Gas
Correct answer: Type 1 respiratory failure — PaO₂ below 8 with a normal or low CO₂
Why
T1RF = PaO₂ below 8 with a normal or low CO₂. It is an oxygenation problem — V/Q mismatch or shunt.
- The low CO₂ tells you she is working hard, blowing it off to compensate
- CO₂ above 6 would put her on the type 2 pathway, which is an entirely different set of decisions — controlled oxygen, NIV, ceiling of care
- A PaO₂ of 7.4 on 4 litres of oxygen is not a normal gas by any reading, and calling this anxiety is how significant hypoxia is dismissed
- The alkalosis is the consequence of the hyperventilation, not the diagnosis
Key point
PaO₂ under 8 with a low CO₂ = T1RF. The low CO₂ is a sign she is working, not a reassurance.
Question 2 · The Differential
Correct answer: Atelectasis, pneumonia or aspiration, PE, pulmonary oedema, and ARDS
Why
Atelectasis (post-operative day 1–2), pneumonia or aspiration, PE at any time, oedema from fluids or cardiac cause, and ARDS.
- PE deserves particular attention because it is the one with no physical signs and a normal chest X-ray — the pathway flags unexplained refractory hypoxia as a specific prompt to re-ask about PE
- COPD and asthma are obstructive and typically produce type 2 failure when severe, though they can cause hypoxia too
- Anaemia impairs oxygen carriage but does not lower PaO₂; sepsis is a cause of ARDS rather than a direct answer here
Key point
Atelectasis, pneumonia, PE, oedema, ARDS. PE is the one with a normal examination and a normal film.
Question 3 · Oxygen
Correct answer: 94–98%, prescribed with a target — escalating device from cannulae to mask to 15L non-rebreathe as needed
Why
Target 94–98%, and prescribe it with the target written down.
- Escalate the device to achieve the target: nasal cannulae → mask → 15L non-rebreathe
- 88–92% is only for known CO₂ retainers — applying it to a type 1 patient under-oxygenates them
- Maximum flow regardless is not titration, and in a patient who might turn out to be a retainer it is the error that causes hypercapnia
- Oxygen is a drug and should be prescribed — with a target range, like any other
Key point
94–98% and prescribe it. 88–92% belongs to retainers only — do not apply it by reflex.
Question 4 · Post-Operative
Correct answer: Analgesia, sit her up, physiotherapy and incentive spirometry — analgesia IS respiratory treatment here
Why
Post-operative: analgesia, sit up, physio, incentive spirometry. A splinted abdomen cannot ventilate — analgesia treats the hypoxia.
- That framing is the point: pain relief here is not comfort, it is the respiratory intervention
- Atelectasis is the commonest cause of post-operative hypoxia and responds to expansion, not antibiotics
- Antibiotics are for genuine pneumonia — not for atelectasis fever alone. Atelectasis causes fever, and treating every post-op fever with antibiotics is how resistance and C. difficile follow
- CPAP is an escalation for refractory hypoxia, not a first move for treatable atelectasis
Key point
Analgesia is the respiratory treatment. A splinted abdomen cannot ventilate, however much oxygen you give it.
Question 5 · Trajectory
Correct answer: A rising oxygen requirement is an escalation trigger in itself
Why
A rising oxygen requirement is an escalation trigger. The trend matters more than any single value.
- NEWS and a repeat ABG, and reassess the cause — if the diagnosis was atelectasis and she is getting worse, the diagnosis needs revisiting
- RR above 30 with tiring is pre-arrest
- "The target is being achieved" is exactly the trap: saturations of 94% on 10 litres are far more worrying than 94% on 2 litres, and a saturation chart alone hides that
- A poor mask fit is worth checking and is not the likely explanation for a doubling of requirement overnight
Key point
Record what she is on, not just the saturation. 94% on 10L is a different patient from 94% on 2L.
Question 6 · Handover
Correct answer: The FiO₂ or device and flow alongside the saturation, the trend, the working diagnosis, and the escalation plan
Why
A saturation without the oxygen it took to achieve it is nearly meaningless.
- Hand over the device and flow rate or FiO₂, the trend over the shift, the working diagnosis, and the escalation plan — including whether critical care has been involved
- "Sats 94%" is the single most misleading handover in acute medicine
- The chest X-ray is background; the trajectory is the decision
- If SpO₂ is below 92% on 15L, that is critical care now — and the next person needs to know how close she is to that line
Key point
Always hand over the oxygen with the saturation. "Sats 94%" on its own tells the next doctor nothing.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.