Home › Cases › Right Upper Quadrant Pain and Fever
Acute Cholecystitis
Right Upper Quadrant Pain and Fever
6 questions
Question 1 · The Sign
Correct answer: Murphy's sign — arrest of inspiration on RUQ palpation, highly specific for acute cholecystitis
Why
Murphy's sign: arrest of inspiration on palpation of the right upper quadrant. It has high specificity for acute cholecystitis.
- TG18: local signs (Murphy's, RUQ tenderness/guarding) + systemic inflammation (fever, raised WCC/CRP) = suspected; + characteristic imaging = definite.
- She has local and systemic signs: obtain ultrasound to confirm
- Rovsing's sign is RLQ pain on LLQ palpation, in appendicitis
- Cullen's sign is periumbilical bruising, a late and rare finding in severe pancreatitis
Key point
Local signs + systemic inflammation = suspected cholecystitis; add characteristic imaging for definite diagnosis. Murphy’s supports the diagnosis; obtain USS.
Question 2 · The Scan
Correct answer: Gallstones, wall thickening >3mm, pericholecystic fluid, sonographic Murphy's sign, and distension >5cm
Why
All of these together make the diagnosis.
- Gallstones — high sensitivity and specificity, but stones alone are extremely common and do not mean cholecystitis
- Wall thickening >3mm — the hallmark
- Pericholecystic fluid — inflammation
- Sonographic Murphy's sign — probe pressure reproduces the sign
- Gallbladder distension >5cm transverse diameter
- A dilated CBD points towards choledocholithiasis, which is a different and important question — but it is not what confirms cholecystitis
Key point
Stones alone are not cholecystitis. Wall >3mm, pericholecystic fluid and a sonographic Murphy's are what confirm it.
Question 3 · Grading
Correct answer: Grade I (mild) — safe for early laparoscopic cholecystectomy
Why
She meets Grade I because she has no Grade II or III criteria.
- Grade II: any one of WBC >18 ×10⁹/L, tender RUQ mass, symptoms >72 h, or marked local inflammation, without Grade III dysfunction
- Grade III: qualifying dysfunction of any cardiovascular, neurological, respiratory, renal, hepatic or haematological system
- Fever supports diagnosis; WBC >18 is also a severity criterion. Her WBC 14.2 does not meet it
Arrange early surgical management if suitable.
Key point
Grade II: WBC >18, tender mass, >72 h symptoms or marked local inflammation. Grade III: organ dysfunction. Neither = Grade I.
Question 4 · First Measures
Correct answer: Nil by mouth, IV fluid resuscitation with Hartmann's, morphine 5–10mg IV, an antiemetic, and bloods including blood cultures
Why
Nil by mouth, IV Hartmann's, morphine 5–10mg IV titrated, ondansetron 4mg IV, and bloods — FBC, LFTs, amylase, CRP, and blood cultures if febrile.
- Adequate analgesia is safe and does not mask the signs. That is stated explicitly in the pathway, and withholding opioids from a patient in severe pain on the theory that it obscures the examination is both outdated and cruel
- Morphine is safe in biliary disease — the concern about sphincter of Oddi spasm is not clinically significant
- Amylase matters because gallstone pancreatitis is the differential you cannot miss
- Oral fluids and a morning review under-treat an acute surgical admission
Key point
Give the morphine. Adequate analgesia is safe in biliary disease and does not mask the signs.
Question 5 · Antibiotics
Correct answer: Cefuroxime 1.5g IV TDS plus metronidazole 500mg IV TDS
Why
Grade I/II: cefuroxime 1.5g IV TDS plus metronidazole 500mg IV TDS.
- Piperacillin-tazobactam 4.5g IV every 8 hours is reserved for Grade III or septic patients — using it routinely is unnecessary broad-spectrum exposure
- Switch to oral when tolerating diet and apyrexial for 24 hours
- Oral antibiotics are inappropriate in a nil-by-mouth patient with an acute surgical abdomen
- Always check your local trust guidelines — regimens vary meaningfully between hospitals
Key point
Cefuroxime plus metronidazole for Grade I/II; Tazocin for Grade III. Check local policy either way.
Question 6 · Timing Surgery
Correct answer: Early laparoscopic cholecystectomy during this admission if fit, within 1 week of diagnosis
Why
Early laparoscopic cholecystectomy within 1 week of diagnosis if suitable; do not routinely cool off for six weeks.
- Deterioration or failed treatment → urgent surgical reassessment, not waiting 72 h
- High risk is not automatically unfit: selected Grade III patients can have expert-centre surgery; drainage if surgery is unsafe and infection uncontrolled
- Duct dilation/abnormal LFTs without a visible stone: MRCP, then EUS if unresolved; therapeutic ERCP for confirmed stones or urgent drainage in cholangitis
Key point
Early surgery, within 1 week if suitable—not a routine six-week wait. Deterioration needs urgent source-control review.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.