Home › Cases › Refusing an Amputation
Mental Capacity Assessment
Refusing an Amputation
6 questions
Question 1 · Where the Assessment Starts
Correct answer: With Stage 1 — is there an impairment or disturbance in the functioning of his mind or brain?
Why
Stage 1: is there an impairment or disturbance in the functioning of the mind or brain?
- Examples: dementia, delirium, intoxication, brain injury, psychiatric illness, severe learning disability
- If NO, the person has capacity and the assessment ends there. You do not proceed to test his reasoning
- The MCA presumes capacity unless proven otherwise. "He's clearly not thinking straight" is not a starting point — it is the conclusion someone has jumped to
- A cognitive screen may inform Stage 1, but it is not the test and a score does not decide capacity
Key point
Start at Stage 1: is there an impairment of mind or brain? No impairment means the assessment is over.
Question 2 · The Unwise Decision
Correct answer: No — a patient can make an unwise decision and still have capacity
Why
A patient can make an unwise decision and still have capacity. This is stated explicitly in the pathway and it is the core of the Act.
- Capacity is about the process of decision-making, not the outcome
- With no impairment at Stage 1, he has capacity and the assessment does not continue
- Requiring him to justify himself to the team's satisfaction inverts the presumption of capacity — he does not have to persuade you
- A capacitous refusal of treatment is binding, however difficult that is for the team
Key point
An unwise decision is not an incapacitous one. Capacity is about the process, not the outcome.
Question 3 · Decision-Specific
Correct answer: His earlier clearly expressed wishes carry substantial weight in any best interests decision, and may amount to a valid advance decision if the requirements are met
Why
Capacity is decision-specific and time-specific, so a new assessment is needed now. But his earlier views do not evaporate.
- Section 4 Best Interests requires you to consider past wishes, values and beliefs, and a clearly documented recent refusal is powerful evidence of them
- If it meets the requirements it may be a valid Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment (ADRT) — and an ADRT present is an escalation trigger: verify validity and applicability before proceeding
- Treating delirium as erasing his views is wrong; so is treating an informal conversation as automatically binding without checking validity
Key point
Losing capacity does not erase what he said before. Past wishes are a required part of best interests.
Question 4 · Which Ability Fails
Correct answer: He cannot use or weigh the information as part of the decision-making process
Why
Stage 3c — the ability to use or weigh the information.
- The pathway names the causes: acute psychosis, severe depression, mania. A delusional belief prevents information being weighed even when it has been perfectly understood
- He may understand the facts entirely and retain them
- Communication fails only if there is no method of communication possible at all — speech, writing, AAC devices, eye gaze or gesture all count
- Recording which stage failed is part of the documentation requirement
Key point
Delusions break weighing, not understanding. Record which of the four abilities actually failed.
Question 5 · Making It Possible
Correct answer: Take all practicable steps to support the decision — simple language, visual aids, accessible formats, written information, repeat consultations
Why
You must take all practicable steps to help someone decide before concluding they cannot.
- Simple language, visual aids, information in an accessible format
- Written information and repeat consultations support retention — and retention only needs to last long enough to make the decision, not permanently
- Understanding does not require perfect recall
- Family are consulted in best interests if he lacks capacity — they do not consent on his behalf unless they hold a health and welfare LPA
- The Court of Protection is for complex or disputed decisions, not the routine route
Key point
Support the decision before you judge it: simple language, visual aids, repeat visits. Retention need only be momentary.
Question 6 · Recording It
Correct answer: Who assessed, when, for which decision, what information was given and how, why they were found to lack capacity, what was decided in their best interests and who was consulted
Why
The documentation requirement is specific, and a bare conclusion does not meet it. Record:
- WHO assessed, WHEN, and for WHICH decision — because capacity is decision-specific and time-specific
- What information was given and in what format
- WHY they were found to lack capacity — which stage failed
- What was decided in their best interests and who was consulted
- Any ADRT or LPA reviewed
- A cognitive score is not a capacity assessment, and a countersignature does not substitute for reasoning
Key point
Who, when, which decision, what information, which stage failed, who was consulted. A conclusion alone is not a record.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.