Septic Arthritis
The Hot Knee
6 questions
Question 1 · Scoring It
Correct answer: 4 criteria — predicted probability around 99.6%
Why
All four Kocher criteria are met: fever above 38.5°C, non-weight-bearing, ESR above 40, WBC above 12 × 10⁹/L. Four criteria predicts a probability of around 99.6%.
- Also check CRP — above 20 mg/L is suggestive — and serum uric acid, to help distinguish gout
- The urgency is the reason: untreated septic arthritis causes irreversible cartilage destruction within 24 to 48 hours
- The score supports the clinical suspicion; it does not replace the aspirate
Key point
Four Kocher criteria is around 99.6%. Fever >38.5, non-weight-bearing, ESR >40, WBC >12.
Question 2 · The Order
Correct answer: Joint aspiration under sterile conditions — antibiotics start within 1 hour of clinical diagnosis, but after the aspirate
Why
Aspirate before antibiotics. Once antibiotics are given, cultures may be sterilised and the organism never identified — which matters for a 4 to 6 week antibiotic course.
- Under sterile conditions, ultrasound-guided for the hip
- Then antibiotics within 1 hour of clinical diagnosis, after aspiration
- Do NOT delay aspiration awaiting imaging
- The only situation where antibiotics precede the aspirate is a septic patient in whom aspiration cannot be obtained quickly — and that is a senior decision, not a default
Key point
Aspirate, then antibiotics within the hour. Sterilised cultures leave you guessing for six weeks.
Question 3 · What to Send
Correct answer: Gram stain and MC&S, crystal analysis, and white cell count with differential
Why
Gram stain and MC&S, crystal analysis to exclude gout and pseudogout, and white cell count with differential.
- Synovial WBC above 50,000/μL with more than 75% polymorphs is highly suggestive of infection
- Crystal analysis matters even when infection is likely — and remember that infection and crystals can coexist, so finding crystals does not let you off
- Sending for culture alone loses the crystal information and the cell count, both of which inform the decision before cultures return at 48 hours
- Gout can look identical clinically, which is exactly why the fluid decides
Key point
Gram stain, culture, crystals, cell count — all four. Synovial WBC >50,000 with >75% PMNs points at infection.
Question 4 · Which Antibiotic
Correct answer: IV flucloxacillin 2g QDS
Why
IV flucloxacillin 2g QDS is empirical first-line, because Staphylococcus aureus is the commonest organism.
- Vancomycin 15–20mg/kg BD is for MRSA risk — prosthetic joint, healthcare exposure, previous MRSA — with AUC/MIC or trough monitoring, target AUC 400–600 mg·h/L
- Ceftriaxone 1g OD is for gonococcal cover in a sexually active young adult
- Sickle cell disease: add cover for Salmonella
- Always check local policy, but the reasoning behind each choice is what to carry
Key point
Flucloxacillin unless there is a reason not to. MRSA risk → vancomycin; young and sexually active → ceftriaxone.
Question 5 · The Operation
Correct answer: Joint washout within 24 hours — arthroscopic for knee, shoulder and ankle; open for the hip or if arthroscopy fails
Why
Joint washout within 24 hours is the standard of care.
- Arthroscopic washout is preferred for knee, shoulder and ankle. Open washout for the hip, or if arthroscopy fails
- Repeat washout if drainage was inadequate or he fails to improve at 48 to 72 hours
- Leave a drain in situ post-washout if the fluid was purulent
- Waiting 72 hours to see whether antibiotics work spends the window in which cartilage is destroyed — 24 to 48 hours
- Antibiotics do not reliably sterilise a closed purulent collection; the same principle as empyema, cholangitis and toxic megacolon
Key point
Washout within 24 hours. Antibiotics do not sterilise pus in a closed space — this is source control again.
Question 6 · Duration
Correct answer: Total 4–6 weeks, with a minimum of 2 weeks IV, stepping down to oral when clinically improving and CRP is falling
Why
Total antibiotic duration 4 to 6 weeks, with a minimum of 2 weeks IV.
- Step down to oral when clinically improving and the CRP is falling — flucloxacillin 1g QDS PO, or clindamycin 300mg QDS if penicillin-intolerant
- Monitor with daily joint assessment — warmth, effusion, range of movement — and CRP and WBC every 48 to 72 hours, which should trend down
- Repeat aspiration if he deteriorates or the CRP rises, and daily orthopaedic review while an inpatient
- Physiotherapy from day 2 to prevent contracture and stiffness
- A week is far too short; six weeks of IV is unnecessary once he is improving
Key point
4–6 weeks total, at least 2 weeks IV, step down on a falling CRP. Physio from day 2.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.