Home › Cases › Refractory Hypoxia on Fifteen Litres
Type 1 Resp Failure
Refractory Hypoxia on Fifteen Litres
6 questions
Question 1 · The Threshold
Correct answer: Critical care now — SpO₂ below 92% on 15L is an escalation trigger
Why
SpO₂ below 92% on 15L non-rebreathe means critical care now. It is the first escalation trigger in the pathway.
- He also meets the second: RR above 30 and tiring is pre-arrest
- Critical care for CPAP or high-flow nasal oxygen — and NIV only in monitored areas, which a general ward is not
- Another hour on a maximal ward-level treatment that is already failing is an hour spent going backwards
- Call early. Critical care would far rather advise on a patient at this point than receive them at the next
Key point
Under 92% on 15L is the line. He is already past it, and RR 34 puts him past a second one.
Question 2 · Re-Ask the Question
Correct answer: PE — unexplained refractory hypoxia is an escalation trigger to CTPA
Why
Unexplained refractory hypoxia → CTPA for PE. It is a named escalation trigger, and the pathway's own summary says to re-ask whether it is a PE.
- PE is the classic cause of profound hypoxia with a normal chest X-ray and an unremarkable examination — everything else on the differential usually shows something
- PE can occur at any time, not only post-operatively
- Checking the probe and the trace is a reasonable ten-second action and is not the answer to a patient with a respiratory rate of 34
- Anxiety does not cause a PaO₂ of 7 on 15 litres
Key point
Profound hypoxia with a clean chest X-ray and normal examination — think PE. Nothing else looks like nothing.
Question 3 · CPAP
Correct answer: Recruits collapsed alveoli and improves oxygenation by raising functional residual capacity
Why
CPAP applies continuous positive pressure, recruiting collapsed alveoli and raising functional residual capacity — it improves oxygenation.
- That is why it fits type 1 failure, which is an oxygenation problem
- Clearing CO₂ requires augmented tidal volume, which is BiPAP — a pressure difference between inspiration and expiration. That is the type 2 tool
- NIV only in monitored areas
- It does not replace treating the cause — CPAP supports oxygenation while the pneumonia, oedema or PE is treated
Key point
CPAP recruits and oxygenates; BiPAP ventilates and clears CO₂. Type 1 versus type 2 in one line.
Question 4 · ARDS
Correct answer: ARDS — bilateral infiltrates with a precipitant
Why
Bilateral infiltrates plus a precipitant is the ARDS pattern, and bilateral infiltrates with shock is an escalation trigger for the ARDS pathway.
- Sepsis is among the commonest precipitants; others include aspiration, pancreatitis, trauma and transfusion
- The distinction from cardiogenic pulmonary oedema matters and is not always easy — history, fluid balance, echocardiography and the clinical context all contribute
- Fluid overload is worth assessing, and the operative and post-admission fluid balance should be reviewed — but it does not explain a septic patient with refractory hypoxia
- Management is critical care: lung-protective ventilation and treating the precipitant
Key point
Bilateral infiltrates + a precipitant + refractory hypoxia = think ARDS. Treat the precipitant, and get critical care.
Question 5 · Recognising Exhaustion
Correct answer: He may be tiring — a falling respiratory rate with a falling GCS is pre-arrest, and needs immediate reassessment with a repeat gas
Why
RR above 30 and tiring is pre-arrest, and a falling GCS is an escalation trigger. A respiratory rate that halves in an hour is either genuine improvement or exhaustion, and the two look completely different on a gas.
- Repeat the ABG immediately — if the CO₂ is rising, he is failing, not improving
- Check the conscious level. Calm and drowsy are not the same thing
- This is the same pattern as the exhausted COPD patient and the silent chest in asthma: the sign that looks like settling is the sign of failure
- If he is genuinely improving, the gas will show it and nothing is lost by checking
Key point
A halving respiratory rate is improvement or exhaustion. Only the gas tells you which, so get one.
Question 6 · Where NIV Belongs
Correct answer: NIV only in monitored areas — a failing patient needs immediate access to escalation and intubation
Why
NIV only in monitored areas.
- A patient on non-invasive support who fails can deteriorate very quickly, and needs immediate access to escalation and intubation — which a general ward does not have
- It also needs staff who can titrate it, interpret serial gases and recognise failure early
- CPAP and high-flow nasal oxygen do have a role in type 1 failure — that is exactly what critical care are providing. The constraint is the location, not the modality
- The constraint is monitoring and escalation capability, not who signs the prescription
Key point
The constraint is the location, not the machine. Non-invasive support needs somewhere it can fail safely.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.