Home › Cases › Not Improving on NIV
COPD Exacerbation
Not Improving on NIV
6 questions
Question 1 · The One-Hour Gas
Correct answer: Deterioration on NIV — an ITU trigger
Why
pH <7.25 or deterioration on NIV is an explicit ITU escalation trigger.
- The repeat ABG at 1 hour exists precisely to make this decision, and a worsening pH is the answer it was asked to give
- Waiting until 4 hours discards the point of the one-hour gas
- Before you conclude the NIV has failed, check the modifiable things: mask fit and leak, patient synchrony, whether the settings have been titrated, and whether she is tolerating it at all
- IPAP 12–15 and EPAP 4–5 are starting points, meant to be titrated
Key point
Worsening at one hour = ITU trigger. But check mask leak, synchrony and settings before declaring failure.
Question 2 · Settings
Correct answer: The starting range is 12–15 and it is meant to be titrated — an untitrated IPAP is a common reason NIV appears to fail
Why
IPAP 12–15 is a starting range, and it is titrated upwards according to response.
- It is the IPAP–EPAP difference that determines tidal volume, and therefore CO₂ clearance. Leaving IPAP at the starting number is a frequent reason a patient looks like an NIV failure when they have simply been under-treated
- EPAP 4–5 splints the airway and offsets intrinsic PEEP; it is not the driver of ventilation
- There is no fixed ceiling of 12 — higher pressures are used, with tolerance and leak becoming the limiting factors
- Escalate to someone who titrates NIV regularly rather than guessing
Key point
The IPAP–EPAP gradient clears CO₂. An untitrated IPAP is a common reason NIV 'fails'.
Question 3 · Exhaustion
Correct answer: Exhaustion with a rising CO₂ — an anaesthetic escalation trigger
Why
Exhaustion, drowsiness and rising CO₂ is an explicit escalation trigger: call anaesthetics.
- A falling respiratory rate in a patient who has been working at 32 is not improvement — it is the point at which the respiratory muscles fail
- The peaceful appearance is CO₂ narcosis, and it is the sign most likely to falsely reassure
- NIV itself is not sedating
- This is the same pattern as the silent chest in asthma and the ceasing diarrhoea in C. difficile: the sign that looks like improvement is the sign of collapse
Key point
A falling respiratory rate in an exhausted patient is failure, not improvement. Call anaesthetics.
Question 4 · The Ceiling Question
Correct answer: Senior review urgently — an undocumented ceiling of care is an escalation trigger in its own right
Why
Ceiling of care undocumented is an escalation trigger: senior review before escalation.
- The decision needs someone who can weigh her premorbid function, exercise tolerance, home oxygen use, previous admissions and previous ventilation, ideally alongside the patient and family
- Defaulting to intubation is not neutral — invasive ventilation in advanced COPD can be difficult to withdraw from and is not right for everyone
- Nor is it a reason to withhold escalation. The absence of a document is not a decision, and treating it as one is how patients who would benefit are denied ITU
- Make the call now, quickly, with a senior
Key point
No documented ceiling is not a decision either way. It is a reason to get a senior on the phone now.
Question 5 · If NIV Is the Ceiling
Correct answer: Continue optimising NIV, and plan in parallel for symptom control if it fails
Why
A ceiling is not a withdrawal. NIV continues, optimised, because it may still work.
- Keep titrating, keep treating the exacerbation — steroids, antibiotics, air-driven nebulisers, controlled oxygen
- Plan in parallel for what happens if it fails: anticipatory symptom control, particularly for breathlessness and distress, and an honest conversation with her and her family
- Withdrawing immediately abandons a treatment that has a real chance of working
- "Nothing changes" is also wrong — what changes is that the plan now has a defined end point, and everyone including the family should know what it is
Key point
A ceiling is a limit, not a withdrawal. Keep treating hard, and plan for comfort in parallel.
Question 6 · Handing Over
Correct answer: The ABG trend, the current NIV settings, the documented ceiling of care and who agreed it, and the plan if she deteriorates further
Why
The trend, the settings, the ceiling, and the plan.
- The ABG trend matters more than any single gas — the direction of travel is the decision
- Current NIV settings, so the next person knows what has already been tried
- The documented ceiling and who agreed it, so it is not relitigated at 04:00 by someone who has never met her
- What to do if she deteriorates, named explicitly
- The diagnosis alone tells the next doctor nothing they cannot read; the bloods and film are background
Key point
Hand over the trend, the settings, the ceiling and the plan — not the diagnosis.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.