Home › Cases › Thirty-Six Hours In
Hospital-Acquired Pneumonia
Thirty-Six Hours In
6 questions
Question 1 · The boundary
Correct answer: No — under 48 hours, treat as community-acquired whatever ward he is on
Why
48 hours or more after admission is the definition, and under 48 hours: treat as community-acquired, whatever ward they are on.
He was almost certainly incubating this when he arrived. Treating him as HAP means broader antibiotics with no benefit and a real C. difficile cost.
The boundary is arbitrary-looking and is still the boundary. The other limb that would make it HAP is presenting having been discharged in the last 7–10 days, which does not apply to him.
Key point
48 hours. Under it is community-acquired, whatever ward they are lying on.
Question 2 · The other definition
Correct answer: Hospital-acquired — discharged within the last 7 to 10 days counts
Why
The second limb of the definition: presenting having been discharged in the last 7–10 days. She has been colonised by whatever is on your wards, and the antibiotic choice needs to reflect that.
VAP is excluded from this definition — that is an ICU problem, and length of stay does not make a patient ventilated.
Note she would also trigger the resistance-risk limb of recent health or social care contact.
Key point
HAP is ≥48 hours in, OR discharged within the last 7–10 days. VAP is excluded.
Question 3 · Back to Mr Okonkwo
Correct answer: CURB-65, and yes — this is community-acquired pneumonia, which is what it is for
Why
This is the mirror image of the trap in the HAP pathway. CURB-65 is for CAP — and this *is* CAP, by the 48-hour rule, so the score applies normally.
The warning in the HAP pathway is that there is no validated severity score for HAP and using CURB-65 there will mislead you. It is not a warning that CURB-65 stops working when the patient is in a bed.
Getting the classification right is what makes the rest of the decisions right.
Key point
CURB-65 works because this is CAP. The warning is about using it in HAP, where nothing is validated.
Question 4 · The mimics
Correct answer: Aspiration, pulmonary oedema after days of IV fluids, post-operative atelectasis, PE and drug reaction
Why
Those five are the ward mimics named in the pathway, and each has an obvious post-operative reason to be there: aspiration after an anaesthetic, pulmonary oedema after days of maintenance fluid, atelectasis in someone not breathing deeply, PE after surgery and immobility, and a drug reaction to something new.
The others in the list are real but are complications of pneumonia rather than things mistaken for it.
Key point
Rule out aspiration, oedema, atelectasis, PE and drug reaction before you commit.
Question 5 · Day three to five
Correct answer: The community-acquired antibiotic choices — onset day 3 to 5 with none of the resistance triggers can follow them
Why
Onset day 3–5 with none of these can follow the community-acquired choices. It is HAP by timing and it does not need HAP-width antibiotics.
This is the clause that stops the 48-hour rule from automatically escalating everyone, and the reason given is explicit: weigh the C. difficile risk of broad-spectrum cover — that is why this is not automatic.
Waiting for a culture before treating a pneumonia is never right.
Key point
Day 3–5 with no resistance triggers can take the community-acquired choices.
Question 6 · Stopping the next one
Correct answer: Reviewing the PPI — acid suppression is a risk factor and many inpatient PPIs have no indication
Why
Review the PPI. Acid suppression is a risk factor for hospital-acquired pneumonia, and an enormous number of inpatient PPIs were started for no recorded reason and never stopped.
The rest of the step: sit them up 30–45°, swallow assessment after stroke or with a wet voice, mouth care, mobilise, physiotherapy early after surgery, and deprescribe sedatives where you can.
Prophylactic antibiotics are not in it, and physiotherapy is "early after surgery", not universal.
Key point
Sit up, swallow assessment, mouth care, mobilise — and review the PPI and the sedatives.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.