Home › Cases › The Analgesia Is Not Working
Rib Fractures
The Analgesia Is Not Working
6 questions
Question 1 · The bleep
Correct answer: Ask him to take a deep breath in and cough, and watch what happens
Why
The target is a deep breath and a cough, not a pain score. A number out of ten does not tell you whether he can clear a secretion; watching him try does.
A pain score of 7 that still permits a cough and a pain score of 7 that does not are different clinical problems with different answers, and the score cannot distinguish them.
Auscultation matters, but at 2am on day 0 the finding you are looking for has not developed yet. The point of tonight is to stop it developing.
Key point
Assess the function, not the number. Can he take a deep breath and cough?
Question 2 · What he can do
Correct answer: The analgesia has failed, and that is an escalation rather than a dose adjustment
Why
Analgesia that has not worked is an escalation, not a rewrite. He is on regular paracetamol and a regular strong opioid and he still cannot cough — that is a failed plan, and the pathway says what to do about it.
Coaching helps a patient who *can* breathe deeply and is frightened to. It does nothing for one who is mechanically prevented by pain.
There is no "ceiling" here that has been reached — the next step has not been taken yet.
Key point
Failed analgesia is an escalation, not a bigger dose of the same thing.
Question 3 · The escalation
Correct answer: Ask for regional analgesia — a serratus anterior or erector spinae plane block
Why
If pain still prevents deep breathing, ask for regional analgesia — do not keep adding opioid. More opioid in a 68-year-old at 2am buys sedation and a lower respiratory rate, and a sedated patient does not clear secretions either.
Serratus anterior and erector spinae plane blocks are the usual options; some units use paravertebral or epidural.
Ask by name and early: anaesthetics or the acute pain team. The block exists to prevent the pneumonia, so it is worth less on day 3 than it is tonight.
Key point
The answer to opioid that has not worked is a block, not more opioid.
Question 4 · Overnight
Correct answer: Optimise what you can overnight — review the regular prescription, add an NSAID if it is safe, get physiotherapy involved first thing, and escalate if he deteriorates
Why
The block being at 8am does not make the next six hours a waiting room. Check the regular prescription is actually regular and being given; an NSAID is genuinely useful in chest wall pain and is often withheld reflexively — if his renal function, bleeding risk and cardiac history allow, with gastric protection, it is worth adding. Book physiotherapy for first thing rather than for later.
A PCA is not wrong in every unit, but it is more opioid by another route in a patient in whom opioid has already failed to achieve a cough.
And a new oxygen requirement or falling saturations at any point is an escalation in its own right.
Key point
A delayed block does not pause the plan. Optimise the rest, and re-escalate if he drops.
Question 5 · Day three
Correct answer: The pneumonia the whole pathway exists to prevent
Why
Watch for it on day 2–4: rising temperature, new oxygen requirement, falling volumes. He has all three.
Pain does peak at day 2–3, which is exactly why this is the window in which the pneumonia arrives — and why "he is just sore today" is the most dangerous available explanation.
A delayed haemothorax is worth considering, particularly if he were anticoagulated, and the CXR will help distinguish them. But the fever and the falling volumes point one way.
Key point
Day 2–4 with fever, new oxygen requirement and falling volumes is the complication, not the pain curve.
Question 6 · Looking back
Correct answer: The block should have been requested on admission rather than at 2am, because it prevents the complication and is worth less once the complication has started
Why
Escalate to a block early is step 4 of the pathway, and the reason given is exactly this: the block exists to prevent the pneumonia, so it is worth less on day 3.
The decision that produced the day-3 pneumonia was made on day 0, when a man who could not cough was left on a plan that was not working until the next morning.
Prophylactic antibiotics are not in the pathway, and prescribing them instead of fixing the analgesia treats the audit rather than the patient.
Key point
The complication on day 3 was decided on day 0. Ask for the block early.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.