Home › Cases › The Last Access
Line & Catheter Infection
The Last Access
6 questions
Question 1 · A difficult decision
Correct answer: Strong presumption toward removal — but the decision and the access plan belong to nephrology today
Why
Staph aureus in a line is an indication for removal, and difficult access does not change the microbiology — a retained infected line seeds endocarditis, discitis and metastatic abscess.
But this is exactly the case where removal is a specialist decision made today rather than a unilateral one made overnight: she needs a temporary access plan, and the nephrologists own that.
So the F1 position is neither "keep it" nor "pull it now": it is ring nephrology and microbiology today, and say the organism out loud.
Key point
Staph aureus: presume removal — and the access plan is nephrology's, today.
Question 2 · Meanwhile
Correct answer: Assess for sepsis, start empirical antibiotics per local policy, and repeat cultures
Why
Treat the patient. Assess for sepsis and follow Sepsis 6 within the hour if she meets it; empirical antibiotics per local policy, covering Gram-positives including MRSA where plausible, then narrowed with microbiology.
Repeat cultures matter here, because documenting clearance is part of deciding how long to treat and whether there is a deep focus.
Dialysis patients have specific dosing considerations, so involve pharmacy and microbiology rather than prescribing a standard regimen.
Key point
Treat the sepsis now, dose for dialysis with pharmacy. Do not wait for the line decision.
Question 3 · The antibiotic lock
Correct answer: Only as a specialist salvage decision, and not for Staph aureus
Why
Antibiotic locks exist and are occasionally used to salvage a tunnelled line when access is genuinely scarce — but on microbiology advice, and not for Staph aureus, Candida or Pseudomonas, where the failure rate and the complication risk are too high.
They are never a default and never a way of avoiding a difficult conversation.
The honest framing: a lock buys a line, and Staph aureus is the organism where that trade is not worth making.
Key point
Locks are a specialist salvage — and not for Staph aureus.
Question 4 · What to look for
Correct answer: Endocarditis by echocardiogram, and spinal infection if she has any back pain
Why
Staph aureus bacteraemia in a dialysis patient is high risk for metastatic infection. Echocardiography for endocarditis is standard, and back pain earns a whole-spine MRI — dialysis patients with indwelling lines are a classic group for spinal epidural abscess.
Remember the epidural abscess teaching: back pain plus fever is enough, the triad is usually incomplete, and the imaging is the whole spine because skip lesions are common.
Repeat cultures document clearance, and persistence suggests a focus you have not found.
Key point
Echo, and image the whole spine if there is back pain. This group gets epidural abscesses.
Question 5 · The catheter question elsewhere
Correct answer: No — cloudy or smelly urine in a catheterised patient is not an indication to treat
Why
Catheters are colonised within days, essentially always. Cloudy or offensive urine describes colonisation, not infection, and treating it selects resistance without helping the patient.
Treat when there are systemic features. Asymptomatic bacteriuria is not treated outside pregnancy and specific urological procedures.
The question worth asking instead: does this catheter still need to be there? In a catheter-associated infection, changing or removing the catheter is often part of the treatment.
Key point
Cloudy urine is not an indication. Ask whether the catheter is still needed.
Question 6 · The principle
Correct answer: The microbiology sets the presumption on removal; the difficulty of replacing it decides who makes the plan
Why
Two separate questions, and conflating them is the error in both directions. The organism and the clinical picture decide whether the device is safe to keep. The practical difficulty decides who is in the room when the plan is made and how quickly access is replaced.
"Difficult to replace" is a reason for an urgent specialist conversation, never a reason to retain an infected line.
And a peripheral cannula comes out at any suspicion, because it costs nothing — the hard decisions belong to the devices that are hard to replace.
Key point
Microbiology sets the presumption on removal. Difficulty decides who plans the replacement.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.