Home › Cases › Primary vs Secondary Pneumothorax
Pneumothorax
Primary vs Secondary Pneumothorax
6 questions
Question 1 · Primary vs secondary
Correct answer: Primary (no lung disease): aspirate and discharge if successful. Secondary (COPD): admit, chest drain, O2, close monitoring — much higher risk
Why
Primary vs secondary PTX (BTS 2023):
- Primary (no underlying lung disease) = lower risk
- Secondary (underlying lung disease, especially COPD) = higher risk of tension, slower resolution, respiratory compromise
- Secondary: always admit, lower threshold for drain, careful O2 (COPD — target 88-92%)
Key point
Primary PTX: aspirate + discharge if successful. Secondary PTX (COPD etc.): always admit + drain + careful O2. Higher risk.
Question 2 · Size assessment
Correct answer: Rim measurement: measure widest distance between lung edge and chest wall. <1cm = small, 1-2cm = moderate, >2cm = large
Why
BTS 2023 PTX sizing: measure widest rim at any level (not just apex).
- <1cm = small
- 1-2cm = moderate
- >2cm = large
- Or: visible rim >2cm at level of hilum = large (older BTS/ACCP method). Treatment based on size AND symptoms AND primary/secondary status
Key point
BTS 2023 PTX size: measure widest rim. <1cm small, 1-2cm moderate, >2cm large. Size + symptoms + type guide management.
Question 3 · Aspiration technique
Correct answer: 14-16G cannula or aspiration catheter 2nd ICS MCL or 4th-5th ICS AAL. Aspirate until resistance or >2.5L aspirated. CXR post-aspiration
Why
PTX aspiration: 2nd ICS MCL (traditional) or 4th-5th ICS anterior axillary line (ATLS preferred — less neurovascular risk). 14-16G cannula connected to 3-way tap and 50ml syringe. Aspirate until resistance felt or 2.5L aspirated. CXR post-aspiration. Success (lung re-expanded, asymptomatic): discharge with follow-up.
Key point
PTX aspiration: 2nd ICS MCL or 4th-5th ICS AAL. Stop at 2.5L or resistance. CXR post. Discharge if re-expanded.
Question 4 · Failed aspiration
Correct answer: Chest drain insertion (Seldinger small-bore catheter 12-14Fr). Aspirate failed = proceed to drain
Why
Failed aspiration: if persistent PTX after aspiration or if aspiration is inappropriate (secondary, tension, bilateral) → chest drain. Small-bore Seldinger drain (12-14Fr) preferred — less painful, fewer complications than large-bore drain. Connect to underwater seal (not suction unless instructed).
Key point
Failed aspiration → chest drain. Small-bore Seldinger drain (12-14Fr). Underwater seal. Suction only if specified.
Question 5 · Chest drain management
Correct answer: Check drain/tubing and CXR; request respiratory review before adding prescribed low-pressure suction
Why
Persistent PTX despite a drain: check tubing for kinks and confirm drain position and lung expansion on CXR; request respiratory review. No bubbling does not prove re-expansion. Suction is not routine: if prescribed, use high-volume, low-pressure suction (−10 to −20cmH₂O). Persistent failure to re-expand needs thoracic surgical assessment.
Key point
Check drain and CXR; call respiratory. Add suction only if prescribed; seek thoracic surgical assessment for persistent non-expansion.
Question 6 · Persistent air leak
Correct answer: Persistent air leak: air leaking >5 days. Surgical referral for VATS. Consider thoracic surgical opinion from day 3 if leak not slowing
Why
Persistent air leak: continuous or ongoing bubbling >5 days without resolution. Surgical referral from day 3-5 if not slowing. VATS: identifies leak source, staples bullae, pleurodesis. Alternatives (poor surgical candidate): chemical pleurodesis via drain (talc slurry or tetracycline). Do not clamp drain with ongoing bubbling — risk of tension.
Key point
Persistent air leak >5 days: VATS referral. Consider from day 3 if not slowing. Never clamp with bubbling — tension risk.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.