Home › Cases › Fit for Theatre?
Perforated Peptic Ulcer
Fit for Theatre?
6 questions
Question 1 · Who Decides
Correct answer: Alert the on-call surgical registrar or consultant immediately, and arrange anaesthetic review for fitness
Why
Alert the on-call surgical registrar or consultant immediately, and get an anaesthetic review for fitness for emergency surgery.
- Both, in parallel — the surgical decision and the anaesthetic assessment are separate questions and both take time to arrange
- Book an ICU or HDU bed if the Boey score is 2 or more
- Waiting for the morning wastes hours in a condition where perforation over 24 hours is itself a mortality point on the Boey score
- Waiting for a formal report when the diagnosis is already clinically clear delays without adding anything
Key point
Surgeon and anaesthetist in parallel, now. Time itself is a Boey point.
Question 2 · The Score
Correct answer: 1 — around 10%
Why
One point: major medical comorbidity.
- No shock (she is normotensive) and under 24 hours since perforation, so neither of the other points applies
- Score 1 carries a quoted mortality of around 10% — substantial, and a number worth having in mind when consenting her
- Score 0 is under 1%; score 2 is around 45%
- The value of the score is that it makes the risk explicit and shared, rather than an unspoken impression
Key point
Comorbidity alone is one point — around 10% mortality. Worth saying out loud when you consent her.
Question 3 · The Operation
Correct answer: Laparoscopic repair with a Graham patch omentoplasty
Why
Laparoscopic repair with a Graham patch omentoplasty is preferred if the patient is haemodynamically stable and the skill is available.
- A tongue of omentum is used to plug and seal the perforation
- Open laparotomy is indicated where laparoscopy is unavailable, there is widespread contamination, or the patient is haemodynamically unstable
- Open surgery is not gentler in the elderly — the laparoscopic approach generally means less pain, better respiratory function and faster recovery
- Endoscopic closure is not the standard management of free perforation with peritonitis
Key point
Laparoscopic Graham patch if stable and the skill is there. Open for instability or heavy contamination.
Question 4 · The Kidneys
Correct answer: Review the doses of renally cleared drugs, avoid nephrotoxics including NSAIDs, and monitor renal function closely through resuscitation
Why
CKD stage 4 changes several things at once.
- Review renally cleared drug doses with pharmacy, including antibiotic dosing
- Avoid nephrotoxics — and NSAIDs in particular, which are very likely part of why she is here in the first place
- Monitor renal function closely: she is septic, hypovolaemic and about to have an anaesthetic, so an AKI on top of CKD is likely
- Withholding antibiotics in a septic patient is never the answer — you adjust the dose, not the decision
- Hourly urine output via the catheter is part of the pathway and is your best real-time renal monitor
Key point
Adjust the dose, never withhold the antibiotic. And the NSAIDs that caused this are now also nephrotoxic.
Question 5 · Consent
Correct answer: The operation, the realistic mortality given her Boey score, the likelihood of ICU, and what would happen without surgery
Why
A Boey score of 1 means a quoted mortality of around 10%, and she is entitled to that number.
- Cover the likely ICU or HDU stay, and what happens without surgery — conservative management exists but carries its own high risk
- Generic bleeding-and-infection consent understates an emergency laparotomy in a 79-year-old with heart and kidney disease
- Waiting to be asked is not informed consent. People frequently do not know what to ask, and the material risks have to be volunteered
- If she lacks capacity, the MCA best interests framework applies — and her past wishes are part of it
Key point
Tell her the number. A 10% mortality is a material risk she has to be given, not one she has to ask for.
Question 6 · Afterwards
Correct answer: H. pylori eradication once eating — PPI, amoxicillin and clarithromycin for 7 days — plus long-term PPI, and a review of the NSAIDs
Why
Repairing the hole does not treat the ulcer disease.
- H. pylori eradication once she is eating: triple therapy — PPI plus amoxicillin plus clarithromycin for 7 days
- Long-term PPI
- Review the NSAIDs. If they cannot be stopped, gastroprotection is mandatory — and in CKD stage 4 they should probably go anyway
- Repeat endoscopy is often arranged, particularly for gastric ulcers to exclude malignancy, but it is not the whole plan
- Doing nothing further is how the same patient returns with the same perforation
Key point
The repair fixes the hole, not the disease. Eradication, long-term PPI, and stop the NSAIDs.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.