Home › Cases › Fluctuating Capacity in Delirium
Mental Capacity Assessment
Fluctuating Capacity in Delirium
6 questions
Question 1 · Lucid at Four, Confused at Ten
Correct answer: Reassess frequently, treat the reversible cause, and delay non-urgent decisions to a lucid period
Why
Fluctuating capacity in acute delirium: reassess frequently, treat reversible causes, and delay non-urgent decisions. It is on the escalation list in those terms.
- Capacity is time-specific — the finding at 22:00 does not describe her at 16:00, and neither describes her next week
- A PEG decision is rarely so urgent that it cannot wait for a lucid period, or for the delirium to resolve
- Treating one assessment as a permanent verdict, in either direction, is the error
Key point
Capacity is time-specific. Treat the delirium, and take non-urgent decisions when she is at her best.
Question 2 · The Cannula
Correct answer: Assess capacity for this specific decision; if she lacks it, act in her best interests using the least restrictive option
Why
Assess capacity for this specific decision, then apply Section 4 best interests with the least restrictive option principle.
- Pulling at a cannula in delirium is usually not a considered refusal — but that is a conclusion you reach by assessing, not by assuming
- Least restrictive first: reorientation, a familiar person present, distraction, resiting the cannula out of view, reviewing whether IV is still needed
- Sedation is not the first answer, and in an older delirious patient it worsens delirium and increases falls
- Treating every action as either a binding refusal or an obstacle to be overcome both skip the assessment
Key point
Least restrictive option first. Reorientation and a resited cannula before anything sedating.
Question 3 · Keeping Her In
Correct answer: A potential deprivation of liberty requiring DoLS authorisation
Why
This is a potential deprivation of liberty and needs DoLS paperwork.
- The pathway is explicit: if admission to hospital or a care home deprives liberty in a person lacking capacity, complete the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS) form
- Deprivation of liberty without DoLS authorisation is an escalation trigger — unlawful deprivation is a human rights breach
- Calling it routine care does not make it lawful
- The Mental Health Act is for treating mental disorder; delirium from a UTI treated on a medical ward sits under the MCA and DoLS
Key point
Repeatedly preventing someone leaving = deprivation of liberty. Complete the DoLS form — unlawful deprivation is a rights breach.
Question 4 · Who Speaks for Her
Correct answer: Whether the LPA is for health and welfare rather than property and financial affairs, and whether it is registered
Why
Check which LPA it is. A property and financial affairs LPA gives no authority over medical treatment; only a health and welfare LPA does, and it must be registered.
- Where a valid health and welfare LPA exists, that attorney is the decision-maker for decisions within its scope
- "Next of kin" has no legal standing in England and Wales for consent — it is a contact, not a decision-maker
- Family are always consulted in best interests, whether or not there is an LPA
- Ask to see the document. Record what you reviewed
Key point
Health and welfare LPA, registered — or it does not apply to treatment. "Next of kin" has no legal standing.
Question 5 · Nobody to Consult
Correct answer: An IMCA — an Independent Mental Capacity Advocate
Why
Instruct an IMCA — Independent Mental Capacity Advocate.
- The MCA requires an IMCA for people who lack capacity for serious medical treatment or a change of accommodation and who have no appropriate person to consult
- The clinician still makes the best interests decision, but the IMCA represents the patient's interests and must be consulted
- Deciding alone omits a statutory step
- The Court of Protection is for genuinely complex or disputed decisions, not the default when someone is unbefriended
Key point
No family, no attorney → instruct an IMCA. It is a statutory requirement, not a courtesy.
Question 6 · When to Go to Court
Correct answer: Court of Protection — no LPA or ADRT with family disagreement is an escalation trigger
Why
No LPA or ADRT plus family disagreement with clinical best interests is an escalation trigger for a Court of Protection application.
- It is also on the list for complex decisions generally
- Family disagreement is indeed not legally binding — but pressing ahead through genuine, sustained disagreement about a serious decision is exactly what the court exists to resolve
- Deferring to family to keep the peace abandons the patient's best interests
- In practice: senior involvement, a documented best interests meeting, and legal advice come first — most disagreements resolve there
Key point
Sustained family disagreement with no LPA or ADRT → Court of Protection. Senior and legal input first.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.