Home › Cases › Self-Harm — Refusing Treatment
Deliberate Self-Harm
Self-Harm — Refusing Treatment
6 questions
Question 1 · The Situation
Correct answer: Assess his capacity to refuse this specific treatment
Why
Capacity is decision-specific and must be assessed, not assumed either way.
- Alert and oriented does not equal capacitous, and a suicide attempt does not equal incapacitous
- Can he understand, retain, weigh the information, and communicate a decision?
- The weighing element is where impairment most often lies in acute distress
- Document the assessment itself, not just the conclusion
Key point
Assess capacity for this decision, now. Neither orientation nor an overdose settles it by itself.
Question 2 · The Clock
Correct answer: NAC is most effective within 8 hours of ingestion
Why
Time matters more than certainty here.
- NAC is most effective given within 8 hours of ingestion — he is at six
- With a 40-tablet ingestion, treatment should not wait for a level if getting one is delayed
- LFTs rising means damage has already happened; that is far too late to be a trigger
Key point
NAC works best inside 8 hours. Do not let a capacity discussion consume the window.
Question 3 · If He Lacks Capacity
Correct answer: The Mental Capacity Act, in his best interests
Why
The Mental Capacity Act covers treatment of a physical condition in someone lacking capacity.
- Treat in his best interests, using the least restrictive option
- The MHA governs treatment for mental disorder, not for paracetamol poisoning
- This distinction is commonly muddled: the MCA is the right instrument for the NAC
Key point
MCA treats the liver; MHA treats the mind. The overdose is a physical emergency.
Question 4 · If He Has Capacity
Correct answer: His refusal must be respected, with continued engagement and senior involvement
Why
A capacitous refusal of medical treatment must be respected, however uncomfortable.
- Involve a senior clinician and the liaison psychiatry team immediately
- Keep talking; capacity can fluctuate and people change their minds
- Document meticulously
- Sectioning him would not authorise the NAC, because the MHA does not cover treatment of the physical consequence
Key point
A capacitous refusal stands, and the MHA cannot be used to get around it. Escalate and keep engaging.
Question 5 · When the MHA Does Apply
Correct answer: Section 2 MHA for assessment, if he refuses voluntary admission
Why
Now the MHA is the right instrument — this is about the mental disorder.
- Section 2 allows assessment for up to 28 days
- It requires an approved mental health professional and two doctors
- Voluntary admission is always tried first
- Nursing staff and doctors also have holding powers while an assessment is arranged
Key point
Active suicidal intent and refusing admission is when Section 2 applies. Not for the physical treatment.
Question 6 · The Distinction
Correct answer: Capacity is decision-specific, and the MCA and MHA do different jobs
Why
Two frameworks, two purposes.
- Capacity is assessed for each decision, at the time it is made, and can fluctuate
- MCA: treatment of physical illness when capacity is absent, in best interests
- MHA: assessment and treatment of mental disorder
- Getting this wrong is both a legal problem and a clinical one, and it is the commonest confusion in these cases
Key point
MCA for the body, MHA for the mind, and capacity assessed decision by decision.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.