Home › Cases › Paradoxical Movement
Rib Fractures
Paradoxical Movement
6 questions
Question 1 · Recognising it
Correct answer: Three or more consecutive ribs fractured in two or more places
Why
Flail segment: 3 or more consecutive ribs fractured in 2 or more places, with paradoxical movement. The segment is disconnected from the rest of the chest wall, so it follows pressure rather than the muscles.
Two adjacent ribs broken in one place each stays attached at both ends and does not flail. A sternal flail exists but is a different pattern.
The paradox is often easier to feel than to see, and is masked entirely once a patient is ventilated with positive pressure.
Key point
3+ consecutive ribs, 2+ places each. Positive pressure ventilation hides it.
Question 2 · What actually harms
Correct answer: The underlying pulmonary contusion and the pain, which together cause respiratory failure
Why
The paradox looks dramatic and contributes, but the injury that kills is underneath: the force that broke six rib ends also bruised the lung, and the pulmonary contusion evolves over 24 to 48 hours.
Add pain severe enough to prevent any deep breath, and you get respiratory failure from two directions at once.
Rib ends do lacerate lung and cause pneumothorax and haemothorax — worth looking for, but not the main mechanism of deterioration in a flail.
Key point
The danger is the contusion under it plus the pain, and the contusion gets worse before it gets better.
Question 3 · Escalation
Correct answer: Critical care now — he is above the threshold and is failing in front of you
Why
STUMBL 26 or more — discuss with critical care. He is at 31, and the score is now the least of it: a new oxygen requirement or falling saturations at any point is an escalation, and he is tiring on a reservoir mask.
The pain team and the surgeons both have a role, and neither of them is the call you make while a man is failing in front of you.
Flail segment, or paradoxical chest wall movement is on the escalation list in its own right, independent of any score.
Key point
STUMBL ≥26 → critical care. A flail escalates on its own, score or no score.
Question 4 · The operation
Correct answer: Flail chest, failure to wean from ventilation, severe pain uncontrolled despite a block, or significantly displaced fractures with chest wall deformity
Why
Those four are the indications in the pathway: flail chest, failure to wean, severe pain not controlled despite a block, and significantly displaced fractures with chest wall deformity.
Number of ribs and age drive the risk — and therefore the STUMBL score and the level of care — but they are not on their own an indication to operate.
Anticoagulation is a consideration for the operation, not a reason for one.
Key point
Fixation is for flail, failure to wean, uncontrolled pain despite a block, or deformity — not for a rib count.
Question 5 · Timing
Correct answer: The local chest wall injury or thoracic service, and yes — fixation is generally better within 72 hours
Why
Refer to the local chest wall injury or thoracic service. Fixation is time-sensitive and is generally better within 72 hours — waiting for the contusion to settle means operating on a patient who has already had the ventilator days and the pneumonia you were trying to avoid.
Which team holds this varies between hospitals, which is why the pathway says *the local service* rather than naming one. Find out who yours is before you need them at 3am.
Key point
Local chest wall injury or thoracic service, and generally better within 72 hours.
Question 6 · The thing not to do
Correct answer: Never strap or bind the chest — it reduces expansion and causes the complication it appears to prevent
Why
Avoid strapping or binding the chest. It looks supportive, it reduces chest expansion, and reduced expansion is the exact mechanism by which these patients develop pneumonia.
It persists as a suggestion because it once was standard practice and because it appears to address the visible abnormality. The visible abnormality is not what is harming him — the contusion under it and the pain are.
The things that genuinely help are analgesia good enough to permit a cough, a block, physiotherapy from day one, and an early conversation about fixation.
Key point
Never strap the chest. It treats the appearance and causes the complication.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.