Home › Cases › NIV Failure — Decision to Intubate
Type 2 Resp Failure
NIV Failure — Decision to Intubate
6 questions
Question 1 · NIV indication review
Correct answer: pH improving towards 7.35, pCO2 falling, RR decreasing, patient tolerating mask
Why
NIV response at 1 hour: pH should be rising (target >7.30 at 1h). If pH static or worsening, pCO2 not falling, RR not improving, or patient increasingly distressed — NIV is failing. Escalation decision must be made within 4 hours of starting NIV.
Key point
NIV: reassess at 1h. pH rising + pCO2 falling = success. Static/worsening = escalate. Decision by 4h.
Question 2 · NIV failure criteria
Correct answer: NIV failure — pH worsening, pCO2 rising, GCS falling. Urgent decision required
Why
NIV failure criteria: pH worsening despite 1-4h treatment, pCO2 rising, GCS falling, haemodynamic instability, worsening hypoxia, inability to tolerate mask. All present here. Immediate decision: intubation (if appropriate for the patient) or ceiling of care discussion.
Key point
NIV failure: worsening pH, rising CO2, falling GCS. Decision must be made now — not after 2 more hours.
Question 3 · Ceilings of care
Correct answer: Call anaesthetics/ICU urgently and review the escalation plan in parallel, including capacity, advance decisions and the patient’s wishes
Why
Call anaesthetics/ICU urgently for deteriorating NIV failure; confirm the response. Review the escalation plan in parallel, including capacity, applicable advance decisions and the patient’s wishes. Involve the patient if able, family and senior clinician; document the decision. Consider likely benefit and burdens of invasive ventilation. Ideally agree the failure plan before starting NIV; an unfinished discussion must not delay urgent specialist assessment.
Key point
Failing NIV: call anaesthetics/ICU now, reviewing the escalation plan and patient’s wishes in parallel.
Question 4 · Intubation in COPD
Correct answer: Dynamic hyperinflation (breath stacking), high airway pressures, difficult weaning, VAP, difficult extubation (may be NIV-dependent)
Why
COPD intubation risks: dynamic hyperinflation (auto-PEEP from air trapping — can cause VF if severe). Ventilator settings: low rate, long expiratory time (I:E 1:4-5), low PEEP. Difficult weaning — may need prolonged NIV after extubation. High pneumothorax risk.
Key point
COPD intubation: dynamic hyperinflation risk. Long expiratory time. Difficult weaning. High pneumothorax risk.
Question 5 · Doxapram alternative
Correct answer: IV doxapram infusion (respiratory stimulant) may be used as bridge. Opioids and anxiolytics for symptom control and comfort
Why
When intubation declined: IV doxapram (respiratory stimulant) may help as a bridge when NIV fails. More commonly: if treatment escalation inappropriate, symptom management with opioids (reduces respiratory distress) and anxiolytics. Palliative care team involvement. Emphasise comfort.
Key point
NIV failing, intubation declined: doxapram as bridge OR palliative opioids/anxiolytics for comfort. Palliative team.
Question 6 · Post-extubation NIV
Correct answer: Planned immediate post-extubation NIV in COPD reduces extubation failure and re-intubation rate
Why
Post-extubation prophylactic NIV in COPD: strong evidence that planned immediate NIV after extubation reduces extubation failure rate by 50% (Ferrer study). Should be planned before extubation for high-risk COPD patients. Not reactive — preventive.
Key point
Planned post-extubation NIV in COPD: reduces re-intubation by 50%. Prophylactic, not reactive.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.