Home › Cases › The Advance Decision in the Notes
Mental Capacity Assessment
The Advance Decision in the Notes
6 questions
Question 1 · A Document Arrives
Correct answer: Verify its validity and applicability to this situation before proceeding
Why
Verify validity and applicability before proceeding. The escalation list states it in exactly those words.
- Validity: made when he had capacity, not withdrawn, and not contradicted by later behaviour inconsistent with it
- Applicability: does it actually cover these circumstances and this treatment?
- A valid and applicable ADRT refusing treatment is legally binding — but that conclusion follows the check, it does not replace it
- Disregarding it is unlawful if it is valid and applicable; following it unchecked risks withholding treatment he would have wanted
Key point
An ADRT is binding if valid and applicable — and establishing that is a step, not an assumption.
Question 2 · Life-Sustaining Treatment
Correct answer: It must be in writing, signed and witnessed, and contain an express statement that it applies even if life is at risk
Why
An advance decision refusing life-sustaining treatment must be in writing, signed by the person and by a witness, and must state expressly that it applies even if life is at risk.
- Advance decisions about other treatments can be verbal; life-sustaining treatment is the exception with stricter formalities
- A GP countersignature is not required, though a copy in the GP record helps it be found
- If the formalities are not met it is not a binding ADRT — but it remains powerful evidence of his past wishes and must be weighed in a best interests decision under Section 4
Key point
Refusing life-sustaining treatment needs writing, signature, witness, and "even if life is at risk" in terms.
Question 3 · Refuse Versus Demand
Correct answer: No — an advance decision can refuse treatment, but nobody can demand treatment that is not clinically indicated. It is a weighty advance statement of wishes
Why
An ADRT can refuse; it cannot compel. No patient, in advance or in the moment, can require a clinician to give treatment that is not clinically indicated.
- A written request is an advance statement of wishes, and it carries real weight in a Section 4 best interests assessment — past wishes, values and beliefs are a required consideration
- "Disregard entirely" is wrong: it is not binding, but it is important evidence of who he is and what matters to him
- The asymmetry is the point: refusals bind, requests inform
Key point
Refusals bind, requests inform. An ADRT cannot compel treatment that is not clinically indicated.
Question 4 · Which Takes Precedence
Correct answer: An LPA made after a valid ADRT, if it gives the attorney authority over the same treatment, can supersede it — this needs senior and legal input
Why
Timing and scope both matter. A health and welfare LPA created after an advance decision, giving the attorney authority over the same treatment, can supersede that decision.
- The reverse is also true — an ADRT made after an LPA takes precedence over the attorney for that decision
- This is a genuinely complex legal question and is precisely when to involve senior clinicians and the trust's legal team, and potentially the Court of Protection
- The clinical team does not simply take over, but nor is the ADRT automatically supreme
Key point
Whichever came later can supersede — but only within its scope. Get senior and legal input rather than deciding alone.
Question 5 · While You Check
Correct answer: Provide treatment that is immediately necessary to sustain life or prevent serious deterioration while the position is clarified urgently
Why
Where there is genuine doubt about validity or applicability, treatment necessary to sustain life or prevent serious deterioration may be provided while the position is resolved.
- The MCA does not require you to withhold urgently needed treatment on the basis of a document you cannot yet verify
- Escalate urgently: senior clinician, and legal advice out of hours if needed
- Document the doubt and the reasoning, in the terms the pathway requires
- Withholding everything on an unverified document risks an unlawful and irreversible omission
- A relative cannot consent on an adult's behalf unless they hold a registered health and welfare LPA
Key point
Genuine doubt → treat while you clarify urgently. Document the doubt and the reasoning at the time.
Question 6 · The Younger Patient
Correct answer: The Mental Capacity Act applies from age 16 for most decisions, so this sits outside it — parental consent or a court order, with paediatric and legal input urgently
Why
A patient under 16 with disputed capacity or refusal is an escalation trigger: parental consent or court order, consult the paediatric team and legal.
- The MCA applies from 16 for most decisions; below that, competence is assessed under Gillick and the framework is different
- Crucially, a competent minor's consent and their refusal are not treated symmetrically in English law — refusal of life-saving treatment by a minor can be overridden by those with parental responsibility or by the court
- Treat this as urgent: paediatrics, seniors and legal advice now, alongside resuscitation
- This is a legally and ethically contested area and is never a decision to make alone at 03:00
Key point
Under 16 refusing life-saving treatment: paediatrics and legal, now. Consent and refusal are not symmetrical in minors.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.