Home › Cases › He Wants to Leave
Acute Psychosis
He Wants to Leave
6 questions
Question 1 · An Inpatient Trying to Go
Correct answer: Section 5(2) — the doctor's holding power, up to 72 hours for an inpatient
Why
Section 5(2) is the doctor's holding power for an existing inpatient — up to 72 hours.
- It buys time for a full Mental Health Act assessment; it is not itself a treatment order
- Section 136 is a police power, used in a public place, allowing detention in a place of safety for up to 24 hours
- Section 2 requires two doctors — one Section 12 approved — plus an AMHP, which takes time to assemble. That is exactly the gap 5(2) exists to fill
- Once 5(2) is used, the full assessment must be arranged urgently, not at leisure
Key point
5(2) is the inpatient holding power — 72 hours, one doctor. It buys time for the real assessment.
Question 2 · Section 2 or 3
Correct answer: Section 2 is for assessment, up to 28 days; Section 3 is for treatment, up to 6 months and requires that appropriate treatment is available
Why
Section 2: assessment, up to 28 days. Section 3: treatment, up to 6 months.
- Section 2 criteria: a mental disorder warranting assessment, and detention necessary for the health or safety of the patient or the protection of others
- Section 3 criteria: a mental disorder warranting treatment, and appropriate treatment available
- Both require two doctors — one Section 12 approved — plus an AMHP
- Neither is voluntary; both are compulsory powers, and neither is defined by age
Key point
2 is assessment for 28 days; 3 is treatment for 6 months. Both need two doctors and an AMHP.
Question 3 · The Right Act
Correct answer: The Mental Capacity Act — treatment of a physical condition in someone lacking capacity, with best interests and least restrictive option; a DoLS authorisation may be needed
Why
The MHA authorises treatment for mental disorder. Treating the hyponatraemia is treatment of a physical condition, and that sits under the Mental Capacity Act.
- Section 4 best interests, and the least restrictive option
- If the arrangements amount to a deprivation of liberty, a DoLS authorisation is needed — and unlawful deprivation is a human rights breach
- The boundary between the two Acts is genuinely difficult and is a senior and often legal decision, not one to settle alone at 03:00
- "Nothing can be done" is wrong — a patient lacking capacity can lawfully be treated in their best interests
Key point
MHA treats the mental disorder; MCA treats the sodium. The boundary is a senior conversation.
Question 4 · Who Is Needed
Correct answer: Two doctors, at least one Section 12 approved, plus an AMHP
Why
Two doctors — one of whom must be Section 12 approved — plus an AMHP (Approved Mental Health Professional).
- The AMHP makes the application; the doctors provide the medical recommendations
- The Nearest Relative has defined rights under the Act, including in some circumstances the ability to object — but this is a specific legal role, not the same as "next of kin", and their agreement is not simply a requirement
- Two doctors of any grade is not sufficient — the Section 12 approval requirement exists specifically to ensure psychiatric expertise
- If you are asked to do this as a foundation doctor, that is a moment to involve a senior
Key point
Two doctors, one Section 12 approved, plus an AMHP. Nearest Relative is a legal role, not a synonym for next of kin.
Question 5 · Section 136
Correct answer: A police power to remove someone from a public place to a place of safety, for up to 24 hours
Why
Section 136 is a police power — removal from a public place to a place of safety, for up to 24 hours.
- It exists to allow assessment, and the clock is short
- Section 5(2) is the 72-hour inpatient holding power, used by a doctor — a different section and a different situation
- It is not a Section 2. A 136 must be converted to a formal assessment, or the person released, within the period
- Practically: the clock starts on arrival at the place of safety, so arranging the MHA assessment early matters
Key point
136 is police, public place, 24 hours. 5(2) is a doctor, an inpatient, 72 hours. Do not mix them up.
Question 6 · The Underlying Duty
Correct answer: That the organic cause must still be excluded and treated — detention is not a diagnosis
Why
Detention is a legal framework for keeping someone safe. It is not a diagnosis and it is not treatment.
- The pathway's first and highest priority remains: exclude organic causes — encephalitis, hypoglycaemia, hyponatraemia, thyroid storm, uraemia, intoxication or withdrawal
- Patients detained under the MHA still need their U&E, glucose, TFTs, imaging and, where indicated, an LP
- The specific danger is that once someone is on a psychiatric pathway, the medical work-up quietly stops
- Psychiatric assessment sits alongside medical assessment; it never replaces it
Key point
Detention is not a diagnosis. The commonest failure is the medical work-up stopping once psychiatry is involved.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.