Home › Cases › Not Getting Better
Septic Arthritis
Not Getting Better
6 questions
Question 1 · Day Three
Correct answer: Inadequate drainage or failure to respond — repeat washout is indicated at 48–72 hours, and the joint should be re-aspirated
Why
Repeat washout if drainage was inadequate or there is failure to improve at 48 to 72 hours — and repeat aspiration if there is clinical deterioration or a rising CRP.
- Both triggers are present. He is at 72 hours with a rising CRP and a persistent tense effusion
- CRP typically peaks within 48 hours of surgery and then falls; a rising CRP at day 3 is a failing response, not a surgical response
- The re-aspirate also answers a second question — is the organism the one you are treating?
- Drug fever and hypersensitivity are possible but would not explain a tense effusion in the operated joint
Key point
Rising CRP at 48–72 hours means re-aspirate and consider a second washout. It is not a post-op response.
Question 2 · The Organism
Correct answer: Switch to IV vancomycin 15–20mg/kg BD, with AUC/MIC or trough monitoring targeting an AUC of 400–600 mg·h/L
Why
MRSA means vancomycin 15–20mg/kg BD, with monitoring — AUC/MIC or trough levels, target AUC 400–600 mg·h/L.
- Flucloxacillin has no activity against MRSA, so increasing the dose achieves nothing
- Clindamycin 300mg QDS is an oral step-down option for penicillin intolerance, not an addition to a failing regimen against a resistant organism
- This also explains the failure to respond: he has been on an antibiotic the organism is resistant to
- Discuss with microbiology — this is a case that needs their input on agent, duration and monitoring
Key point
Flucloxacillin does nothing against MRSA. No dose of the wrong drug is the right dose.
Question 3 · Why It Was Missed
Correct answer: Healthcare exposure is an MRSA risk factor, so empirical vancomycin would have been the right initial choice
Why
MRSA risk factors are prosthetic joint, healthcare exposure, and previous MRSA. Regular haemodialysis is substantial healthcare exposure.
- Empirical vancomycin rather than flucloxacillin would have been the correct initial choice — and the risk assessment is a question you ask at the point of the first prescription, not afterwards
- His renal failure also affects vancomycin dosing, which is another reason for microbiology and pharmacy involvement
- Ceftriaxone is for gonococcal cover in a sexually active young adult — a different risk group
- The general lesson: the empirical choice follows the risk assessment, and the risk assessment is a question you have to actually ask
Key point
Ask about healthcare exposure before you choose the empirical antibiotic. Dialysis is MRSA risk.
Question 4 · Special Populations
Correct answer: Cover for Salmonella
Why
Sickle cell disease: add cover for Salmonella. It is specified in the pathway.
- Functional hyposplenism and bone infarction in sickle cell disease predispose to Salmonella osteomyelitis and septic arthritis — an association that is classic and easily forgotten
- The other two special cases in the pathway: prosthetic joint or healthcare exposure → vancomycin for MRSA; sexually active young adult → ceftriaxone for gonococcal cover
- Pseudomonas is associated with intravenous drug use and penetrating injuries, and antifungal cover with profound immunosuppression — neither is the sickle cell answer
- Discuss with microbiology in any of these groups
Key point
Sickle cell: cover Salmonella. Three special cases — sickle cell, MRSA risk, and the young sexually active adult.
Question 5 · Long-Term Damage
Correct answer: Physiotherapy from day 2, to prevent contracture and stiffness
Why
Physiotherapy from day 2 to prevent contracture and stiffness.
- It is a named step in the pathway and it is routinely delayed because the joint is painful and everyone is focused on the infection
- Immobilisation causes exactly the stiffness you are trying to avoid, and there is no CRP threshold at which movement becomes safe
- Some damage from the infection itself may be unavoidable — cartilage destruction within 24 to 48 hours is the reason it is an emergency — but the contracture from immobility is preventable
- The parallel with post-fasciotomy care: early movement preserves function while the tissue recovers
Key point
Physio from day 2, not once the CRP is normal. The infection damages cartilage; immobility does the rest.
Question 6 · Stepping Down
Correct answer: After a minimum 2 weeks IV, stepping down to oral when clinically improving with a falling CRP, to complete 4–6 weeks total
Why
Minimum 2 weeks IV, then oral step-down when clinically improving and CRP falling, to a total of 4 to 6 weeks.
- Oral step-down: flucloxacillin 1g QDS, or clindamycin 300mg QDS if penicillin-intolerant — though in his case the MRSA changes the choice and needs microbiology guidance
- A normal CRP does not mean the course is finished — treating to a number rather than a duration is how relapse happens
- Ten days is far too short for septic arthritis and would very likely relapse
- He will need outpatient parenteral antibiotic therapy or a clear oral plan, with follow-up bloods and orthopaedic review
Key point
Two weeks IV minimum, 4–6 weeks total. A normal CRP is not the end of the course.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.