Home › Cases › The One That Was Missed
Ruptured AAA
The One That Was Missed
6 questions
Question 1 · Two Days Ago
Correct answer: That only 25–50% present with the full triad, so an incomplete picture in an older patient still warrants considering AAA
Why
Only 25 to 50% present with the full triad, which means the majority of ruptured and leaking AAAs look like something else at first.
- A contained leak can cause days of pain before catastrophic rupture — the pain is the warning
- Sudden back, flank or abdominal pain in an older patient, particularly a smoker or someone with vascular disease, should prompt at least a bedside aortic ultrasound, which takes minutes
- Calling it unforeseeable removes the learning; the incomplete presentation is precisely what is foreseeable about this condition
- A CT KUB would not have been the right test, though it might have shown the aneurysm incidentally
Key point
The incomplete presentation is the norm, not the exception. A bedside scan takes two minutes.
Question 2 · Now
Correct answer: Call the vascular consultant directly, activate the MHP, give O-negative blood if crossmatch is unavailable, and prepare for theatre — no CT
Why
Unstable means theatre, not the scanner.
- Vascular consultant directly, anaesthetics and theatre alerted simultaneously
- Activate the MHP: 1:1:1. O-negative blood if crossmatch is unavailable and transfusion is essential
- Permissive hypotension still applies — but the target is no numeric SBP target while conscious and mentating, and he is drowsy, which is the specific circumstance in which a 500ml crystalloid bolus is permitted
- Restoring a systolic above 100 would displace the tamponade and is the error the whole concept exists to prevent
- Do not take an unstable patient to CT
Key point
Drowsy is when the 500ml bolus is allowed — and only then. The target is still 50–70.
Question 3 · The Limit of the Rule
Correct answer: The target is no numeric SBP target while conscious and mentating — losing consciousness is the trigger for a 500ml crystalloid bolus
Why
The endpoint is cerebral perfusion, not a number: no numeric SBP target while conscious and mentating.
- Maximum 500ml crystalloid boluses, and only if losing consciousness
- That makes conscious level the monitor, which is why "conscious and mentating" is written into the target
- A systolic of 90 is above the target range, not below it — treating 90 as the floor abandons permissive hypotension entirely
- Lactate is a useful severity marker and will be raised, but it is not the trigger for fluid here
- No GTN, no antihypertensives throughout
Key point
Conscious level is the monitor, not the number. Losing consciousness buys him 500ml, and no more.
Question 4 · Transfer
Correct answer: No — transfer only if the patient is stable. He needs open repair here, or the nearest achievable definitive care
Why
EVAR is not available at all centres — transfer if needed, but only if the patient is stable. He is not.
- Transferring an unstable ruptured AAA means the patient is in an ambulance, without a theatre, when they arrest
- Open repair is indicated where EVAR equipment or expertise is unavailable, and the retroperitoneal approach is preferred for ruptured AAA because it gives better proximal control
- The lower mortality of EVAR applies to patients who survive to have it
- This decision belongs to the vascular consultant and is exactly why they are called directly and early
Key point
Transfer only the stable. An unstable rupture in an ambulance has no theatre.
Question 5 · Duty of Candour
Correct answer: Be honest that he attended and was diagnosed differently, explain what is happening now, avoid speculating about blame, and ensure a senior speaks to them and a formal review follows
Why
Duty of candour applies, and it starts with honesty about the facts rather than a judgement about them.
- Confirm what happened — he attended, was assessed, was diagnosed differently — without speculating on whether that was an error, which you are not in a position to determine mid-resuscitation
- Explain what is happening now, and ensure a senior speaks to them
- A formal review — Datix and, if he comes to harm, a serious incident investigation — should follow
- "Nothing could have been done differently" is a conclusion you cannot support and may well be wrong
- Refusing to discuss it looks like concealment and destroys trust at the worst possible moment
Key point
State the facts, do not adjudicate them, and escalate. Refusing to discuss it reads as concealment.
Question 6 · What Changes
Correct answer: A low threshold for bedside aortic ultrasound in any patient over 60 with unexplained abdominal, flank or back pain
Why
A bedside aortic ultrasound is fast, free of radiation, available at the bedside, and gives rapid confirmation in a stable patient.
- Lowering the threshold for that single scan is a proportionate and achievable change, unlike CT for everyone
- CT aortogram for all older patients with back pain would be a huge radiation and contrast burden for a low yield, and would not be deliverable
- The diagnosis is not unpredictable — the incomplete presentation is well described, which is what makes a screening habit possible
- The parallel with cauda equina: the fix is a cheap test applied liberally, not an expensive test applied to everyone
Key point
Make the bedside scan a habit, not a decision. It is two minutes and it catches the incomplete presentation.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.