Home › Cases › Is It Gout or Is It the Other One?
Acute Gout
Is It Gout or Is It the Other One?
6 questions
Question 1 · Reading the Crystals
Correct answer: Calcium pyrophosphate deposition — CPPD, or pseudogout
Why
Rhomboid, positively birefringent crystals are CPPD. Gout is needle-shaped and negatively birefringent.
- The two features go together and are worth memorising as a pair: gout — needles, negative; CPPD — rhomboids, positive
- CPPD favours larger joints — knee and wrist — where gout classically starts at the first MTP joint
- Septic arthritis is diagnosed by organisms on Gram stain or culture, not by crystal morphology — and it can coexist with either crystal type
- Management of an acute CPPD attack is broadly similar — NSAIDs, colchicine or steroid by comorbidity — but urate-lowering therapy has no role
Key point
Gout: needles, negative. CPPD: rhomboids, positive. Learn them as a pair.
Question 2 · The Urate Trap
Correct answer: Very little — serum urate may be normal during an acute attack
Why
Serum urate may be normal during a flare, so 310 µmol/L does not exclude gout.
- If gout remains strongly suspected, repeat at least two weeks after the flare settles
- A raised urate supports the clinical diagnosis in a typical presentation, but asymptomatic hyperuricaemia is common
- Use aspiration/crystal microscopy when the diagnosis is uncertain; assess infection separately
- Treatment target: urate <360 µmol/L (<300 with tophi)
Key point
Normal urate during a flare does not exclude gout. Repeat ≥2 weeks after settling if still suspected; use the result with the clinical picture.
Question 3 · When You Cannot Aspirate
Correct answer: Escalate — any suspicion of septic arthritis means aspirate and orthopaedics urgently; the aspirate should be obtained by someone who can
Why
Any suspicion of septic arthritis means aspirate plus orthopaedics urgently. If you cannot do it, find someone who can — that is the escalation.
- Small joints can be septic, and "rarely" is not a basis for treating blind
- Blind antibiotics before an aspirate compromise the culture and may leave the diagnosis permanently unclear, while an undrained septic joint continues to destroy cartilage
- In sepsis or septic shock, start antibiotics promptly without waiting for aspiration, alongside urgent senior help; the aspirate and drainage are chased, not abandoned
- Orthopaedics can aspirate, and so can rheumatology in hours
Key point
Suspected septic joint: urgent aspiration + orthopaedics. If septic/shocked, antibiotics now without waiting; continue arranging drainage.
Question 4 · The Timing Rule
Correct answer: Usually plan the start 2–4 weeks after this first flare settles; starting during a flare is an option with frequent flares
Why
Usually start ULT 2–4 weeks after the flare settles, with a written plan and follow-up.
- Frequent flares: NICE NG219 allows starting during a flare with anti-inflammatory treatment/prophylaxis
- Start allopurinol 100 mg daily; 50 mg initially in CKD, with further renal adjustment as needed; titrate using monthly urate
- Falling urate can mobilise crystals and trigger flares during initiation; explain this and offer suitable cover
- Continue established allopurinol during a flare
Key point
Usually start 2–4 weeks after settling; frequent flares are an exception. Start low, plan follow-up/cover, and continue established allopurinol.
Question 5 · The Cover
Correct answer: Colchicine cover, if suitable, while titrating to target urate, because falling urate triggers flares
Why
Discuss colchicine prophylaxis while reaching the target urate, if suitable; review duration rather than automatically stopping at six months. Check renal function and interactions.
- The reason is counterintuitive and worth understanding: as urate falls, deposited crystals dissolve and mobilise, which triggers attacks. So starting effective treatment can cause flares in the first months
- Without cover, patients have a flare, conclude the tablets caused it, and stop the one drug that was going to help
- Explaining this to the patient is as important as prescribing the cover
- A PPI is given with NSAIDs, not with allopurinol
Key point
Effective treatment causes flares at first. Cover with colchicine and warn him, or he will stop the allopurinol.
Question 6 · The Genetic Check
Correct answer: HLA-B*58:01
Why
HLA-B*58:01 in at-risk ethnicities, because carriage is strongly associated with severe cutaneous adverse reactions to allopurinol — including SJS/TEN and DRESS.
- Prevalence is higher in Han Chinese, Thai and Korean populations, and testing is recommended in those groups
- G6PD status is checked before primaquine or tafenoquine for malaria radical cure, and before some other oxidant drugs — a different test for a different drug
- TPMT is checked before azathioprine
- Also worth knowing: allopurinol interacts significantly with azathioprine, which is a separate and serious prescribing trap
Key point
HLA-B*58:01 before allopurinol in at-risk ethnicities. Different drug, different genetic test — do not confuse them.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.