Home › Cases › Mental Capacity Assessment
Mental Capacity Assessment
Mental Capacity Assessment
6 questions
Question 1 · The Four-Stage Test
Correct answer: Ability to understand the information, retain it, weigh it up (use and apply it), and communicate a decision
Why
The Mental Capacity Act 2005 defines capacity via a two-stage, four-part test: Stage 1: Is there an impairment or disturbance in the functioning of the mind or brain? If yes, Stage 2: Does this cause inability in one or more of the four domains: (1) Understand — comprehend the information relevant to the decision in broad terms; (2) Retain — hold the information long enough to make the decision (even briefly); (3) Weigh up (use and apply) — deliberate and use the information to arrive at a decision; (4) Communicate — by any means (speech, writing, gestures, AAC). Failing any one of the four means the patient lacks capacity for that decision. Assess each domain explicitly and document findings. MMSE is a cognitive screen — it does NOT equate to capacity.
Key point
MCA 2005 capacity test: can the patient Understand, Retain, Weigh up, and Communicate? — failing any one of these four domains means they lack capacity for that specific decision.
Question 2 · Presumption of Capacity
Correct answer: Incorrect — the MCA 2005 states that every adult must be presumed to have capacity unless proven otherwise through a structured assessment
Why
The first principle of the MCA 2005 is the presumption of capacity: 'A person must be assumed to have capacity unless it is established that he lacks capacity.' The burden of proof lies with the clinician to demonstrate lack of capacity — not with the patient to prove they have it. Confusion, older age, dementia diagnosis, or an unusual decision are NOT sufficient alone to conclude lack of capacity. The MCA also enshrines: (2) all practicable steps to support capacity must be taken first (e.g. timing the assessment when the patient is most alert, using an interpreter, providing information in accessible formats); (3) an unwise decision does not equal lack of capacity — patients have the right to make decisions others consider unwise. Gerald's capacity must be formally assessed, documented, and justified.
Key point
The MCA 2005 presumes capacity — you must prove lack of capacity through structured assessment; confusion, age, or an unwise decision alone do NOT indicate incapacity.
Question 3 · Best Interests Decision Making
Correct answer: A best interests decision must be made under MCA 2005 s4 — involving the clinical team, family/carers, and any IMCA if there is no one to consult, considering the patient's wishes, values, and beliefs
Why
When a patient lacks capacity, treatment decisions are governed by MCA 2005 Section 4 — Best Interests. The decision-maker (usually the treating clinician for day-to-day decisions) must: (1) Consider all relevant circumstances including past and present wishes, feelings, beliefs, and values; (2) Consult family members, carers, and others involved in care — though they cannot consent on his behalf (no proxy decision-making in England/Wales unless a Lasting Power of Attorney for Health and Welfare (HCEW-LPA) is registered); (3) If the patient has no one to consult and the decision is serious, appoint an Independent Mental Capacity Advocate (IMCA); (4) Seek the least restrictive option. Document the best interests rationale fully. An HCEW-LPA holder CAN consent or refuse on behalf of the patient.
Key point
When capacity is absent, make a best interests decision under MCA s4 — consult family/carers (they advise but cannot consent), check for a Health and Welfare LPA, and appoint an IMCA if the patient has no one to consult.
Question 4 · Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards
Correct answer: Yes — if a person lacks capacity and is deprived of their liberty (not free to leave, under continuous supervision and control), DoLS authorisation must be sought from the supervisory body (local authority)
Why
DoLS (Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards) apply under MCA 2005 Schedule A1 in hospitals and care homes where a person: (1) lacks capacity; and (2) is deprived of their liberty — defined in the Cheshire West Supreme Court judgment (2014) as being under continuous supervision and control and not free to leave. Bed rails + 1:1 nursing + restricted movement = likely DoLS situation. The managing authority (hospital) must apply to the supervisory body (local authority) for a Standard Authorisation — or an Urgent Authorisation can be self-granted for up to 7 days pending the Standard Authorisation. From 2022, Liberty Protection Safeguards (LPS) are intended to replace DoLS but implementation has been repeatedly delayed. Under-recognition of DoLS requirements is a significant NHS governance risk.
Key point
DoLS are required in hospital when a person lacks capacity and is under continuous supervision and control and not free to leave — apply to the local authority as supervisory body; grant Urgent Authorisation (7 days) immediately if needed.
Question 5 · Court of Protection
Correct answer: Escalate to the Court of Protection, which has jurisdiction over all decisions relating to people who lack mental capacity
Why
The Court of Protection (CoP) is the specialist court established by MCA 2005 to make decisions about the property, finances, health, and welfare of people who lack mental capacity. The CoP can: appoint a deputy to make ongoing decisions; make one-off decisions on specific matters (e.g. whether to proceed with surgery); review or override clinical best interests decisions; and grant or revoke LPA registrations. Any interested party — including family members — can apply to the CoP. In urgent situations, the CoP can convene within hours. The Hospital Trusts NHS Legal team should be contacted early if legal challenge is anticipated. A Clinical Ethics Committee (CEC) provides non-binding advisory guidance and is a useful step before CoP in non-urgent disputes. Clinicians should document all discussions thoroughly.
Key point
The Court of Protection has jurisdiction over all welfare decisions for those lacking capacity — family can apply to challenge best interests decisions; in disputes, involve the Trust's legal team and consider the Clinical Ethics Committee first.
Question 6 · Documentation
Correct answer: Document the decision-specific assessment: date/time, the decision assessed, impairment identified, findings for each of the four MCA domains, consultation with family, best interests reasoning, least restrictive option considered, and any advance decisions or LPAs checked
Why
Thorough documentation of capacity assessments is both a legal and professional obligation under the MCA Code of Practice and GMC Good Medical Practice. A robust capacity record should include: (1) The specific decision being assessed (not generic 'capacity' — capacity is decision-specific and time-specific); (2) Date and time of assessment; (3) Evidence of impairment (e.g. delirium, dementia); (4) Explicit assessment of each of the four MCA domains with the patient's actual responses; (5) Conclusion on capacity with reasoning; (6) For best interests: who was consulted (names, relationship), what the patient's past wishes and values were, what options were considered, and why the chosen option is least restrictive; (7) Whether any Advance Decision to Refuse Treatment (ADRT) or LPA was identified and checked. Poor documentation is a major source of medicolegal risk.
Key point
Document capacity assessments specifically and thoroughly: the decision assessed, findings for all four MCA domains, consultation with family, best interests rationale, least restrictive option, and any ADRT or LPA identified — vague notes are medicolegally indefensible.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.