Home › Cases › Deliberate Self-Harm Assessment
Deliberate Self-Harm
Deliberate Self-Harm Assessment
6 questions
Question 1 · Medical Stabilisation First
Correct answer: Perform a primary survey (A-E assessment), calculate time and dose of ingestion, check paracetamol level, and initiate N-acetylcysteine (NAC) treatment per MHRA guidelines
Why
Medical stabilisation always takes priority over psychiatric assessment in deliberate self-harm. For paracetamol overdose: (1) A-E assessment — airway, breathing, circulation, disability (GCS, BM), exposure; (2) Calculate dose ingested: 30 × 500mg = 15g total — this is above the treatment threshold in most adults (>75mg/kg or >5g); (3) Check paracetamol level at 4 hours post-ingestion (earlier levels are unreliable); (4) Initiate N-acetylcysteine (NAC / Parvolex) per the MHRA/TOXBASE nomogram — treatment threshold has been simplified (2019 update) to a single line; (5) LFTs, INR, U&E, VBG to assess hepatotoxicity. NEVER delay physical treatment pending psychiatric assessment. NPIS (National Poisons Information Service) / TOXBASE should be consulted for all overdoses.
Key point
Medical first, psychiatry second — in paracetamol overdose, check the level at 4 hours, use the MHRA treatment nomogram, and start N-acetylcysteine (NAC) if above threshold before any psychiatric assessment.
Question 2 · Risk Assessment
Correct answer: NICE recommends structured clinical judgement informed by validated tools — not algorithmic scoring tools like SADPERSONS alone, which have poor predictive value for suicide
Why
NICE NG225 (2022) Self-Harm Guideline recommends structured clinical judgement rather than the use of risk scoring tools (such as SADPERSONS, Columbia, or Manchester Self-Harm Rule) as the sole basis for decision-making. Evidence shows that tools like SADPERSONS have poor sensitivity and specificity for predicting future suicide or self-harm repetition and can give false reassurance or over-medicalise low-risk presentations. Structured clinical assessment should include: precipitating factors, mental state, intent and lethality of attempt, protective factors (reasons for living, social support), previous history of self-harm or mental illness, current suicidal ideation, and access to means. NICE 2022 also emphasises a trauma-informed, compassionate approach — many patients with self-harm have histories of abuse and adverse childhood experiences.
Key point
NICE NG225 (2022) recommends structured clinical judgement over risk scoring tools like SADPERSONS — assess precipitants, intent, lethality, mental state, and protective factors using a compassionate, trauma-informed approach.
Question 3 · Intent and Lethality
Correct answer: These features indicate HIGH lethality and HIGH intent: planned attempt, precautions against discovery, large dose, did not seek help, expressed wish to die — this significantly increases the risk of future completed suicide
Why
Assessing the intent and lethality of a self-harm act is crucial. High-risk features in this vignette include: Planning (thought about it for days — not impulsive); Precautions against discovery (alone at home, told no one — significantly increases risk); Large dose (15g paracetamol — objectively lethal without treatment); Did not seek help after the act; Expressed suicidal intent ('wanted to die'); Found by chance — survival was not the intended outcome. The Pierce Suicidal Intent Scale and clinical assessment frameworks identify these as markers of serious intent. Contrast with lower-risk features: impulsive act after argument, told someone immediately, took a small dose, sought help themselves. Jasmine's presentation warrants psychiatric inpatient admission for safety and further assessment — discharge would not be appropriate.
Key point
High-risk self-harm features: planned attempt, precautions against discovery, high-lethality method, no help-seeking, expressed wish to die — these strongly predict future completed suicide and generally indicate inpatient admission.
Question 4 · Mental State Examination
Correct answer: Appearance and behaviour, speech, mood (subjective and objective), thought (form, content, suicidal ideation), perceptions (hallucinations), cognition, insight
Why
A Mental State Examination (MSE) is a structured assessment of current mental functioning — analogous to a physical examination for psychiatry. All junior doctors managing self-harm patients should be able to perform and document a basic MSE: (1) Appearance and behaviour — self-care, eye contact, agitation, psychomotor retardation; (2) Speech — rate, volume, rhythm, coherence; (3) Mood — subjective (patient's own words: 'how do you feel?') and objective (clinician's observation: appears tearful, flat affect); (4) Thought form and content — thought disorder, suicidal ideation (current, passive vs active, intent, plan, access to means), hopelessness; (5) Perceptions — hallucinations (auditory commands to self-harm?); (6) Cognition — orientation, concentration; (7) Insight — does she recognise she has a problem and needs help? Document in SOAP format. Active suicidal ideation with a plan and access to means is a psychiatric emergency.
Key point
A full MSE includes: appearance, speech, mood (subjective + objective), thought (form + content + suicidal ideation), perceptions, cognition, and insight — all junior doctors should be able to perform and document this.
Question 5 · Safe Discharge vs Psychiatric Admission
Correct answer: Psychiatric inpatient admission — either informally if she agrees or via MHA Section 2 if she refuses and meets criteria
Why
Jasmine has multiple indicators for inpatient psychiatric admission: persistent active suicidal ideation, inability to engage with a safety plan, no protective social support, and a severe depressive episode. NICE NG225 (2022) states that decisions about admission should be based on a holistic assessment — not a scoring tool — with focus on imminent risk and ability to keep safe in the community. Informal admission is preferred if the patient consents; if she refuses and meets criteria for detention (risk to herself due to mental disorder), Section 2 MHA may be appropriate (see Scenario 70). Safety planning (identifying warning signs, coping strategies, trusted contacts, emergency numbers, means restriction) is a key component of community discharge for lower-risk patients. IAPT is not appropriate for active suicidal crises — waiting lists are too long and intensity is insufficient. Discharge without adequate psychiatric support from a high-risk presentation is medicolegally and ethically indefensible.
Key point
Persistent suicidal ideation + inability to safety plan + no social support = inpatient psychiatric admission; if patient refuses and meets MHA criteria, consider Section 2 — never discharge a high-risk patient without psychiatric input and a clear safety plan.
Question 6 · Safeguarding and Documentation
Correct answer: An adult safeguarding concern may override confidentiality — follow the Trust's adult safeguarding policy, consider MARAC/DASH referral for domestic abuse, document all disclosures carefully, and explain information sharing to the patient
Why
This situation involves adult safeguarding and domestic abuse. Key principles: (1) Confidentiality can be overridden when there is a serious public interest or risk to life — under the Care Act 2014, local authorities have duties to safeguard adults at risk; (2) Follow the Trust's Adult Safeguarding Policy — make a referral to the Adult Safeguarding Team; (3) Consider a DASH (Domestic Abuse, Stalking and Honour-based violence) risk assessment — a high score triggers MARAC (Multi-Agency Risk Assessment Conference) referral; (4) IDVA (Independent Domestic Violence Advisor) referral for advocacy; (5) Explain to Jasmine what information will be shared and why — maintaining trust even when overriding confidentiality; (6) In England, the Domestic Abuse Act 2021 and NICE PH50 provide frameworks. Document all disclosures verbatim using inverted commas, note the injuries and their consistency with the history, and the safeguarding actions taken. If children are in the household, a Section 47 Children Act 1989 referral may also be necessary.
Key point
Domestic abuse disclosures require adult safeguarding referral under the Care Act 2014 — complete a DASH risk assessment, consider MARAC referral, document all disclosures verbatim, and explain information sharing to the patient; confidentiality may be overridden to protect life.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.