Open Fracture
Open Fracture
6 questions
Question 1 · Initial Assessment
Correct answer: Follow ATLS primary survey — address airway, breathing, and circulation before wound assessment
Why
In any trauma patient, ATLS (Advanced Trauma Life Support) principles dictate that primary survey (ABCDE) takes absolute priority over assessment of individual injuries. This patient has haemodynamic compromise (HR 118, BP 98/62) suggesting haemorrhagic shock — addressing circulatory compromise with IV access, fluid resuscitation, and cross-matching blood is critical. The open fracture is part of 'C' (Circulation) — haemorrhage control with direct pressure is important. Jumping to wound irrigation without addressing the primary survey risks missing life-threatening injuries. A tourniquet is appropriate for arterial haemorrhage but should not replace ATLS assessment.
Key point
ATLS primary survey first in all trauma — haemodynamic instability takes priority over open fracture wound management.
Question 2 · Wound Assessment and Contamination Management
Correct answer: Photograph the wound, irrigate with 3–6 litres of normal saline, apply a moist saline dressing, and do not remove again until theatre
Why
BOAST 4 (British Orthopaedic Association Standards for Trauma) guidelines on open fractures specify: photograph the wound before covering (to document Gustilo grade and avoid repeated re-examination), irrigate with 3–6 litres of normal saline (not antiseptic — antiseptics are cytotoxic to healing tissue), and apply a moist saline dressing. Crucially, the wound should not be disturbed again until theatre — repeated examination increases infection risk. The Gustilo-Anderson classification (I, II, IIIA, IIIB, IIIC) guides management: Grade IIIB indicates extensive periosteal stripping requiring soft tissue coverage. Scrubbing the wound causes tissue damage and is contraindicated.
Key point
Open fractures: photograph, saline irrigate, moist dressing, leave until theatre — never scrub or use antiseptics per BOAST 4.
Question 3 · IV Antibiotics
Correct answer: Co-amoxiclav 1.2g IV immediately; for heavily contaminated wounds add gentamicin 5mg/kg IV
Why
BOAST 4 mandates IV antibiotics within 1 hour of injury in open fractures. For most open fractures (Gustilo I–IIIA), co-amoxiclav 1.2g IV is the recommended agent — it covers gram-positive, gram-negative, and anaerobic organisms. For heavily contaminated wounds (Gustilo IIIB/IIIC) or farm/aquatic contamination, gentamicin 5 mg/kg IV is added. This combination covers *Clostridium* species (gas gangrene risk). If penicillin-allergic, clindamycin is substituted. Flucloxacillin alone has insufficient gram-negative cover. Oral antibiotics are never appropriate — bioavailability is unreliable in haemodynamically compromised patients and timing is critical.
Key point
Co-amoxiclav IV within 1 hour of injury for open fractures; add gentamicin for heavily contaminated wounds per BOAST 4.
Question 4 · Tetanus Prophylaxis
Correct answer: Give both tetanus immunoglobulin (TIG) and a tetanus toxoid booster, as this is a tetanus-prone wound with uncertain vaccination status
Why
Tetanus-prone wounds include wounds contaminated with soil, manure, or road debris, puncture wounds, and those with devitalised tissue. When vaccination history is uncertain, Public Health England (PHE) guidance recommends both tetanus immunoglobulin (TIG) 250 units IM (to provide immediate passive immunity) and tetanus toxoid booster (to stimulate active immunity). TIG alone is used in known fully vaccinated individuals with tetanus-prone wounds. Tetanus, though rare in the UK due to the childhood immunisation programme, carries a 25% mortality rate once symptomatic. A contaminated open tibial fracture is a classic high-risk scenario and should never be dismissed.
Key point
Uncertain vaccination + tetanus-prone wound = TIG + toxoid booster — both agents are needed per PHE guidelines.
Question 5 · Time to Definitive Surgery
Correct answer: Skeletal stabilisation and debridement within 24 hours; definitive soft tissue coverage within 72 hours of injury
Why
BOAST 4 updated guidance (2017) states that debridement and skeletal stabilisation should occur within 24 hours for most open fractures, ideally in daylight hours by a senior orthopaedic and plastic surgery team. Definitive soft tissue coverage (flap reconstruction or split skin grafting) should be achieved within 72 hours of injury. The old '6-hour rule' has been superseded — evidence shows outcomes are not improved by emergency out-of-hours surgery provided antibiotics are given promptly. Primary wound closure is contraindicated in heavily contaminated open fractures due to infection risk. A combined ortho-plastic approach is mandated for Grade IIIB/IIIC injuries.
Key point
Debridement within 24 hours, soft tissue coverage within 72 hours — the '6-hour rule' is obsolete per updated BOAST 4 (2017).
Question 6 · Complications
Correct answer: Probable osteomyelitis — obtain deep bone cultures (biopsy or swab at surgery) before starting long-term antibiotics
Why
Osteomyelitis is a serious complication of open fractures, characterised by bone pain, sinus formation, elevated inflammatory markers, and XR changes (periosteal reaction, sequestrum, involucrum). Crucially, deep bone cultures must be obtained before antibiotics — superficial wound swabs are unreliable and antibiotic pre-treatment results in culture-negative osteomyelitis, hampering targeted therapy. Management involves surgical debridement of infected and necrotic bone, followed by prolonged IV antibiotics guided by sensitivities (typically 6 weeks). Non-union is another complication of open fractures, but the sinus and raised CRP point to infection. Gas gangrene (*Clostridium perfringens*) presents more acutely with crepitus and rapid deterioration — not at 6 weeks.
Key point
Osteomyelitis after open fracture = deep bone biopsy for cultures before antibiotics — superficial swabs and empirical treatment without cultures lead to treatment failure.
Case complete
Practice on this page does not update your app progress. Open the browser app if you want its learning tools and progress record.